← 글 목록← All articles

Is double patenting a problem for Korean divisional applications?

Brief summary

  • Yes. A divisional application is deemed filed at the time the original application (parent application) was filed (Patent Act, Art. 52(2)). If a claimed invention is identical to one claimed in the original application, Art. 36(2) of the Patent Act on applications filed on the same date applies.
  • The comparison is between the inventions stated in the claims of the two applications. Identity is judged claim by claim, and it includes substantial identity.
  • A violation of Art. 36(2) is a ground for rejection. After registration, it is a ground for a request for revocation of a granted patent and for a trial for invalidation.
  • During examination, the conflict is removed by an amendment that makes the claimed invention different or deletes the claim. After registration, abandoning one of the two patent rights does not remove it.

This article is based on the Patent Act (특허법) in force from 11 November 2025 and the Patent Examination Guidelines (특허·실용신안 심사기준) in force from 13 March 2026. Last verified on 9 October 2026. Of the provisions cited in this article, the amended Patent Act that is scheduled to take effect on 16 March 2027 changes only Art. 81-3. [7]

Last verified

How each case is handled at a glance

Case Handling Basis
A claim of the divisional application is the same invention as a claim of the original application The divisional application is accepted as a divisional and is examined under Art. 36(2) of the Patent Act Examination Guidelines, Part 6, Chapter 1, 3.3(3)
The claims became identical after the division, through an amendment of the original application or of the divisional application Same as above Examination Guidelines, Part 6, Chapter 1, 3.3(3)
The claim of the divisional application is an invention that was only in the description of the invention or the drawings of the original application The original application does not need to be amended Examination Guidelines, Part 6, Chapter 1, 4.(2)
The original application has not yet received a decision to grant (same applicant) The examiner does not examine Art. 36(2) and notifies the other grounds for rejection Examination Guidelines, Part 3, Chapter 5, 4.4(3)②
The original application has already received a decision to grant (same applicant) A ground for rejection under Art. 36(2) is notified for the divisional application Examination Guidelines, Part 3, Chapter 5, 4.4(3)①
The applicant divided out part of the registered invention of a registered original application and requested a trial for correction Examination of the divisional application is suspended until the trial for correction ends Examination Guidelines, Part 6, Chapter 1, 6.2(5)②
One of the applications was abandoned, invalidated or withdrawn That application is deemed never to have been filed Patent Act, Art. 36(4), subparagraph 1
Both are registered Ground for a request for revocation of a granted patent, ground for invalidation Patent Act, Art. 132-2(1), subparagraph 2, and Art. 133(1), subparagraph 1
Both are registered and one patent right was then abandoned The conflict is not removed Examination Guidelines, Part 3, Chapter 5, 5.(1); Supreme Court Decision 2005Hu3017

The fourth and fifth rows apply in the same way when the divisional application receives a decision to grant before the original application. The Examination Guidelines call the two applications “the present application” and “the conflicting application”. They do not distinguish which is the original application and which is the divisional application. [3]

A divisional application is deemed filed on the same date as the original application

Between a divisional application and its original application, the provision that applies is Art. 36(2) of the Patent Act, not Art. 36(1). The reason is that the main clause of Art. 52(2) deems the divisional application to have been filed at the time the original application was filed. [1]

The proviso to Art. 52(2) lists four cases in which the time the divisional application was actually filed is used instead. Art. 36 is not among those four cases. [1] The Examination Guidelines also state that, for the earlier-application rule, the reference date of a divisional application is the filing date of the original application. [3]

Art. 36(2) of the Patent Act provides that, for identical inventions filed on the same date, only the one applicant chosen by consultation between the applicants (협의) can obtain a patent. If no agreement is reached or no consultation is possible, no applicant can obtain a patent for that invention. [1]

The Examination Guidelines deal directly with the case where an invention stated in the claims of the divisional application is identical to an invention stated in the claims of the original application. In that case the divisional application itself is accepted, and it is examined under Art. 36(2) of the Patent Act. The same applies where the inventions were different at the time of division but became identical through an amendment of the original application or of the divisional application. [3]

Divisional applications from the same original application are also treated, under Art. 36, as filed on the same date as each other. The reason is that Art. 52(2) of the Patent Act deems each divisional application to have been filed at the time the original application was filed. [1] Part 3, Chapter 5, 4.1(1)④ of the Examination Guidelines also gives the filing date of the original application as the reference date of a divisional application. [3]

The same applies to a separational application (splitting-off) (분리출원). Art. 52-2(2) of the Patent Act applies Art. 52(2) mutatis mutandis. [1] The separational application provisions have an applicability provision (Addenda to Act No. 18505, Art. 4). They apply to separational applications from an application for which an appeal against the examiner’s decision to reject a patent application (trial on rulings rejecting patent applications) was filed on or after 20 April 2022. [1] The Examination Guidelines note that a separational application sometimes states a claim identical to a claim of the original application. [3]

Art. 36 applies regardless of whether the inventors or the applicants are the same. [3] An original application and a divisional application of the same applicant are also covered. The Examination Guidelines state that, in practice, most conflicting applications arise because the claims of the original application were incorrectly amended when the divisional application was filed. [3]

The term of the patent of a divisional application is also set by the filing date of the original application. The term of the patent runs from the date of registration of the grant of a patent (registration of establishment of a patent right) to the date 20 years after the filing date of the patent application (Patent Act, Art. 88(1)). [1] The four years used for the patent term extension for delay in registration (extension of the term of a patent right following delayed registration) are counted differently. For that purpose, notwithstanding Art. 52(2), the date on which the divisional application was filed is deemed the filing date (Patent Act, Art. 92-2(4)). [1]

The comparison is between the inventions stated in the claims

Identity under Art. 36 of the Patent Act is judged between the inventions stated in the claims of the two applications. The Examination Guidelines state that the test is whether the technical ideas are identical, and that when there are two or more claims the judgment is made claim by claim. [3]

A divisional application usually has the same description of the invention and drawings as the original application. What the Examination Guidelines name as the object of comparison under Art. 36 is the invention stated in a claim. It is not the description of the invention or the drawings (Examination Guidelines, Part 3, Chapter 5, 3.1(1)). [3]

If there is no difference in the configuration, the inventions are identical. Even if there is a difference in the configuration, the inventions are treated as identical if they are substantially identical. [3] The Examination Guidelines explain substantial identity as the case where the difference lies only in non-essential matters and does not affect the idea of the invention. The examples given are a mere difference in expression, a mere change in configuration, and the mere existence or absence of a use limitation. [3]

Changing the category of a claim may not be enough to avoid identity. The Examination Guidelines treat a mere difference in category as a mere difference in expression. [3] The Supreme Court of Korea (대법원) ruled to the same effect in Supreme Court Decision 2005Hu3017 Decided January 12, 2007. The fact that one invention is a product invention and the other is a process invention does not by itself mean that the inventions are not identical. [4] Supreme Court Decision 2007Hu2827 Decided September 24, 2009 is to the same effect. [5] Both decisions are cases to which the Patent Act before amendment applied.

A difference between a generic concept and a specific concept can raise the same issue. The Examination Guidelines treat as identical the difference where an invention of a specific concept in the earlier application is expressed as an invention of a generic concept in the later application (Part 3, Chapter 5, 5.(5)). [3] That sentence is written on the premise of an earlier application and a later application.

The wording of Art. 36 of the Patent Act is “identical invention”. [1] For the judgment of identity under Art. 36, the Examination Guidelines use the identity standard of the chapter on the enlarged concept of novelty (Part 3, Chapter 4, Section 6). [3] That section cites Supreme Court Decision 2017Hu2369, 2376 Decided September 16, 2021. [3] That decision treated as substantial identity a minor difference that is no more than the addition, deletion or change of well-known and commonly used techniques and produces no new effect. It also stated that, if the difference goes beyond that, the inventions cannot be called identical even if the difference is within what a person skilled in the art could easily derive. [8] That decision is a case under Art. 29(3) of the former Patent Act, not under Art. 36 of the Patent Act. [8]

With the same applicant, the ground for rejection may not be raised until one application receives a decision to grant

A case in which a patent cannot be obtained under Art. 36(2) of the Patent Act is a ground for rejection (Patent Act, Art. 62, subparagraph 1). [1] However, the time at which it is notified depends on the status of the other application.

The order of examination where the applicants are the same is set out in Part 3, Chapter 5, 4.4(3) of the Examination Guidelines. [3]

  1. If the conflicting application has not yet received a decision to grant, the examiner does not examine the ground for rejection under Art. 36(2) and notifies the other grounds for rejection.
  2. When the application is examined again after all notified grounds for rejection have been overcome, the examiner grants it if it is still not decided whether the conflicting application will be patented. This is the case where there is no ground for rejection other than Art. 36(2).
  3. If, when the application is examined again, the conflicting application has received a decision to grant, the examiner notifies the ground for rejection under Art. 36(2). If the claims of the present application were amended later than the last amendment of the claims of the conflicting application, it is notified in a notice of final rejection.
  4. Even before a decision to grant, if a ground for rejection under Art. 36(2) is expected, the examiner may notify it together with the other grounds for rejection. In that case the examiner also issues a request for consultation.

If the applicants are different, the order is different. This is the case where the divisional application has been assigned. If the conflicting application has been laid open and examination has been requested for it, the examiner issues a request for consultation in the name of the Minister of Intellectual Property. The ground for rejection under Art. 36(2) is also notified for both applications at the same time (Examination Guidelines, Part 3, Chapter 5, 4.4(2)①). [3]

The request for consultation is the procedure of Art. 36(6) of the Patent Act. The Minister of Intellectual Property sets a period and orders the applicants to report the result of the consultation. If no report is filed within that period, it is deemed that no agreement was reached. [1] If an agreement is reached, the Notice of Change of Right Relations (Form 20 of the Enforcement Rules of the Patent Act) must be filed. The procedure that follows from the result of the consultation must be taken at the same time (Enforcement Rules of the Patent Act (특허법 시행규칙), Art. 34). [2] If only the report is filed and the procedure is not carried out, the case is handled as if no agreement had been reached. [3]

Where one of the applications has already been patented, no consultation is possible. [3] If no consultation is possible, no applicant can obtain a patent for that invention (Patent Act, proviso to Art. 36(2)). [1]

The applicant can remove the ground by amendment, without consultation. The Examination Guidelines state that the ground for rejection can be overcome by filing a written amendment that makes the conflicting invention different or deletes it. [3] An amendment can be filed until the certified copy of the decision to grant is served. After a notice of grounds for rejection has been received, an amendment can be filed only within the period for submission of a written argument or when requesting re-examination (Patent Act, Art. 47(1)). [1]

The content of the amendment is also restricted. The restriction applies to an amendment filed after a notice of grounds for rejection that addresses grounds caused by an earlier amendment, and to an amendment filed when requesting re-examination. In these situations the claims can be amended only in four cases, such as narrowing the claims by limiting a claim, deleting a claim or adding to a claim (Patent Act, Art. 47(3)). [1]

An application that has received a decision to grant can still be amended before registration. From the date on which the certified copy of the decision to grant is served until registration, the applicant can amend the application and request re-examination (Patent Act, Art. 67-2(1)). [1] There are three cases in which the request cannot be made: where a decision following re-examination has already been issued, where an appeal against the decision to reject has been filed, and where the application is a separational application (proviso to the same paragraph). A request for re-examination cannot be withdrawn (Art. 67-2(4)). [1] Re-examination after a decision to grant applies to applications for which the certified copy of the decision to grant was served on or after 20 April 2022 (Addenda to Act No. 18505, Art. 7). [1]

The Examination Guidelines state that, in general, the original application has to be amended at the same time as the written divisional application is filed. The purpose is to make the inventions stated in the claims of the two applications different. If the invention of the divisional application was only in the description of the invention or the drawings of the original application, the original application does not need to be amended. [3]

For a divisional application filed after the decision to grant, the Examination Guidelines contain separate notes (Part 6, Chapter 1, 6.2(5)). They cover divisional applications from an original application for which the decision to grant was served on or after 29 July 2015. [3] If the applicant divides out part of the registered invention and requests a trial for correction, the examiner suspends examination of the divisional application until the trial for correction ends. If no trial for correction is requested, the examiner examines the application with attention to whether the applications conflict. If they conflict, the examiner states that fact when notifying the grounds for rejection. [3] A trial for correction can be requested in cases such as narrowing the claims (Patent Act, Art. 136(1)). [1] It cannot be requested while a request for revocation of a granted patent or a trial for invalidation is pending before the Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board (Art. 136(2)). [1]

The examiner may also issue a decision of rejection (decision to reject a patent application) on the other grounds for rejection alone, without mentioning the conflicting application. [3]

An application that is abandoned, invalidated or withdrawn is deemed never to have been filed

If one of the applications is abandoned, invalidated or withdrawn, that application is deemed never to have been filed for the purposes of Art. 36 of the Patent Act (Patent Act, Art. 36(4), subparagraph 1). [1] The same applies to an application for which a decision of rejection or a trial decision of rejection has become final (subparagraph 2 of the same paragraph). [1]

There is one exception. An application whose rejection became final under the proviso to Art. 36(2) of the Patent Act, that is, because no agreement was reached or no consultation was possible, is not deemed never to have been filed (Patent Act, proviso to Art. 36(4)). [1] This proviso applies to patent applications filed on or after 3 March 2006 (Addenda to Act No. 7871, Art. 2). [1][3]

An application that received a decision to grant but for which the annual fees were not paid also falls under this rule. If the annual fees are not paid within the period for late payment, the patent application is deemed abandoned. Where the period for late payment has ended but the period for payment of under-paid patent fees has not, the application is deemed abandoned when the under-paid patent fees are not paid within that period (Patent Act, Art. 81(3)). [1] The Examination Guidelines state that in this case the application loses its status as an earlier application. [3]

This abandonment can be reversed. A person who could not pay for good cause can pay the annual fees or the under-paid patent fees within two months from the date on which the cause ceased to exist (Patent Act, Art. 81-3(1)). However, this cannot be done once one year has passed from the expiration date of the period for late payment or of the period for payment of under-paid patent fees, whichever is later (proviso to the same paragraph). If the payment is made, the patent application is deemed not to have been abandoned (Art. 81-3(2)). [1] The Examination Guidelines also describe the case as one where the fees were not paid by the end of the payment period, the period for late payment, the period for payment of under-paid patent fees and the restoration period. [3] The amended Patent Act that takes effect on 16 March 2027 (Act No. 21955) changes the requirements for restoration in Art. 81-3. The amended provision applies to cases in which the period for late payment or the period for payment of under-paid patent fees expires on or after the date it takes effect (Addenda, Art. 2). [7]

After registration, abandoning the patent right does not remove the conflict

If both the original application and the divisional application are registered for an identical invention, the patents are open to two procedures.

Procedure Who When Basis
Request for revocation of a granted patent (특허취소신청) Anyone From the registration date until the date six months after the publication of registration Patent Act, Art. 132-2(1), subparagraph 2
Trial for invalidation An interested party or an examiner Can be requested even after the patent right has been extinguished Patent Act, Art. 133(1), subparagraph 1, and Art. 133(2)

Both procedures can be brought claim by claim. [1] The request for revocation of a granted patent applies to patent rights registered on or after 1 March 2017 (Addenda to Act No. 14035, Art. 10). [1]

Abandoning one of the patent rights after registration is not a solution. The Examination Guidelines state that abandoning a patent right does not create a state in which consultation is possible and does not remove the conflict. [3] The reason is that, unlike abandonment of an application, abandonment of a patent right has no retroactive effect. [3]

The decision behind this is Supreme Court Decision 2005Hu3017. In that case a patent and a utility model, filed by the same applicant on the same date, were both registered. The right holder abandoned the utility model right before the trial for invalidation was requested. The Supreme Court held that the abandonment did not cure the defect of the conflicting applications, and it upheld the judgment of the lower court, which had found the patent invalid. [4] That decision is a case under the Patent Act as it stood before the amendment of 3 February 2001. The current Examination Guidelines cite the decision as it is. [3]

Invalidation is different. If one of the patents is finally invalidated, the Examination Guidelines treat that application as having lost its status as an earlier application. [3] The reason is that, once a trial decision of invalidation becomes final, the patent right is deemed never to have existed (Patent Act, Art. 133(3)). [1]

How Korea differs

Applicants who are used to US practice are likely to be confused on three points.

Item Korea United States
Scope of the rejection Identical invention (including substantial identity) The same invention type, and the nonstatutory type for claims that are not patentably distinct
Terminal disclaimer Art. 36 of the Patent Act has no provision under which a ground for rejection is avoided by disclaiming part of the term of the patent A rejection of the nonstatutory type can in certain cases be overcome by a terminal disclaimer under 37 CFR 1.321(c) or (d)
Protection of a divisional application filed after a restriction requirement Arts. 36 and 52 of the Patent Act have no provision that excludes divisional applications 35 U.S.C. 121 prevents use as a reference in certain cases

Section 804 of the MPEP of the United States Patent and Trademark Office divides double patenting rejections into two types. One is the same invention type, based on 35 U.S.C. 101. The other is the nonstatutory type, created by case law, which prevents claims that are not patentably distinct from the claims of an earlier patent. [6] A rejection of the nonstatutory type can in certain cases be overcome by a terminal disclaimer. A rejection of the same invention type cannot be overcome by a terminal disclaimer. [6]

Art. 36 of the Korean Patent Act covers only identical inventions. [1] A claim set that was registered in the United States with a terminal disclaimer may be treated differently in Korea. Under the Examination Guidelines, inventions are not identical if there is a difference in the configuration and the difference does not amount to substantial identity. [3]

What Art. 36(2) and Art. 36(4) of the Patent Act provide for is consultation, and the abandonment, invalidation or withdrawal of an application and the rejection of an application becoming final. Art. 36 has no provision under which a ground for rejection is avoided by disclaiming part of the term of the patent. [1] The Examination Guidelines state that abandoning a registered patent right does not remove the conflict. [3]

What applicants should do

  • In general, we suggest placing the claims of the original application and the claims of the divisional application side by side and comparing them when the divisional application is filed. The comparison is best made claim by claim, covering the dependent claims as well as the independent claims.
  • If a claim of the divisional application comes from a claim of the original application, we suggest filing, on the same day, an amendment that deletes or changes that claim in the original application. This is possible only at a time when the original application can be amended.
  • If the original application has already received a decision to grant, we suggest writing the claims of the divisional application differently from the granted claims of the original application.
  • We suggest keeping in mind that a claim in which only the category has been changed (product to process, or process to product) may be judged to be an identical invention.
  • Each time one of the two applications is amended during examination, we suggest comparing it again with the current claims of the other application. Art. 36(2) also applies where the claims became identical through an amendment.
  • When a US claim set is brought into Korea as it is, we suggest first checking whether it contains claims that were written on the assumption of a terminal disclaimer.
  • Please confirm the judgment of identity in an individual case with a Korean agent.

FAQ

If a claim of the divisional application is the same as a claim of the original application, does the divisional application become unlawful as a divisional?

No. The Examination Guidelines state that the divisional application itself is accepted and that it is examined under Art. 36(2) of the Patent Act. [3]

Is a request for consultation issued even when the applicants are the same?

It can be. Art. 36 of the Patent Act applies regardless of whether the applicants are the same. [3] Instead of consultation, the applicant can overcome the ground for rejection by an amendment that makes the invention different or deletes it. [3]

What happens to the divisional application if the original application is withdrawn or abandoned?

An application that is abandoned, invalidated or withdrawn is deemed never to have been filed for the purposes of Art. 36 of the Patent Act (Patent Act, Art. 36(4)). [1] However, abandonment of a patent right after registration does not fall under this rule. [3][4]

Can a terminal disclaimer be filed in Korea?

Art. 36 of the Patent Act has no provision under which a ground for rejection is avoided by disclaiming part of the term of the patent. [1] The Supreme Court held that abandoning one of the rights after registration does not cure the defect of the conflicting applications. [4]

How DEFINE IP Law Firm handles this

When filing a divisional application, DEFINE IP Law Firm compares the claims of the original application and the claims of the divisional application claim by claim. We repeat the same comparison whenever either application is amended. Subject matter of claims that are removed is recorded separately as a candidate for a divisional application. For questions about the claim structure of Korean divisional applications, please write to contact@defineip.kr.

Sources

  1. Patent Act (특허법), Act No. 21134, in force from 11 November 2025. Articles 36, 47, 52, 52-2, 62, 67-2, 81, 81-3, 88, 92-2, 132-2, 133 and 136; Addenda to Act No. 7871 (in force from 3 March 2006) Art. 2; Addenda to Act No. 14035 (in force from 1 March 2017) Art. 10; Addenda to Act No. 18505 (in force from 20 April 2022) Arts. 4 and 7. https://www.law.go.kr/법령/특허법 (verified 9 October 2026)
  2. Enforcement Rules of the Patent Act (특허법 시행규칙), Prime Ministerial Decree No. 2115, in force from 14 May 2026. Article 34. https://www.law.go.kr/법령/특허법시행규칙 (verified 9 October 2026)
  3. Ministry of Intellectual Property (지식재산처), Patent Examination Guidelines (특허·실용신안 심사기준), MOIP Established Rule No. 7, in force from 13 March 2026. Part 3, Chapter 4, 6.2 and 6.3; Part 3, Chapter 5; Part 6, Chapter 1, 3.3, 4. and 6.2(5). https://www.law.go.kr/행정규칙/특허·실용신안심사기준 (verified 9 October 2026)
  4. Supreme Court of Korea (대법원), Supreme Court Decision 2005Hu3017 (2005후3017) Decided January 12, 2007. https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2005후3017) (verified 9 October 2026)
  5. Supreme Court of Korea (대법원), Supreme Court Decision 2007Hu2827 (2007후2827) Decided September 24, 2009. https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2007후2827) (verified 9 October 2026)
  6. USPTO, Manual of Patent Examining Procedure § 804 Definition of Double Patenting [R-07.2022]. https://www.uspto.gov/web/offices/pac/mpep/s804.html (verified 9 October 2026)
  7. Patent Act (특허법), Act No. 21955, promulgated on 15 September 2026, scheduled to take effect on 16 March 2027. Article 81-3; Addenda, Art. 2. https://www.law.go.kr/법령/특허법 (verified 9 October 2026)
  8. Supreme Court of Korea (대법원), Supreme Court Decision 2017Hu2369, 2376 (2017후2369, 2376) Decided September 16, 2021. https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2017후2369) (verified 9 October 2026)