Brief summary
- The Supreme Court of Korea held that, in principle, a patent right is effective only within the territory of the country where it is registered. However, where four circumstances all exist, the case is exceptionally treated as if the product working (practicing) the patented invention had been manufactured in Korea. [1]
- The four circumstances are as follows. All the components or elements, or a semi-finished product that has all the main elements, are manufactured in Korea. They are exported to a single entity, and processing and assembly at the final stage are planned. That processing and assembly are extremely minor or simple. The manufacturing of all the components or of the semi-finished product alone reaches a state in which the function and effect of the invention can be realized. [1]
- The act that this decision found to be infringement is manufacturing in Korea, not exporting. In its decision of 15 May 2025, the Supreme Court stated that whether a case falls under this exception must be judged strictly. [1] [3]
This article is based on the Patent Act (특허법) (Act No. 21134) in force from 11 November 2025. Last verified on 9 October 2026.
Last verified
The case
| Item | Details |
|---|---|
| Court | Supreme Court of Korea |
| Date of decision | 17 October 2019 |
| Case number | 2019Da222782, 222799 |
| Case name | Injunction against Infringement on Patent Rights, etc. (both cases) |
| Lower court | Patent Court Decision 2018Na1220, 1237 Decided February 19, 2019 |
| Result | Of the part of the lower judgment against the Plaintiff, a portion is reversed and remanded to the Intellectual Property High Court of Korea (Patent Court of Korea) (특허법원). The remainder of the Plaintiff’s final appeal and the Defendants’ final appeals are dismissed |
| En banc or not | It is not an en banc decision. It was decided by the assent of all four participating Justices |
| Reference Provisions (as stated in the decision) | [1] Patent Act, Art. 98, Art. 126, Art. 128 / [2] Patent Act, Art. 97 / [3] Patent Act, Art. 94, Art. 127, subparagraph 1 / [4] Patent Act, Art. 130 |
The content of this table is taken from the written judgment. [1] The numbers before the Reference Provisions are the numbers that the written judgment gives to its Main Issues and Holdings. The subject of this article, the exception to territoriality, is Main Issues and Holdings [3].
The issue: is it “manufacturing” to make the components separately and have them assembled abroad?
The patented invention is an invention of a product relating to an instrument used in a procedure. The Plaintiff is the patentee, and it claimed an injunction against infringement, damages and other relief. [1]
There are four Defendants. The written judgment refers to three of them together. This article calls those three “the three Defendants”. The remaining Defendant is a subcontractor. [1]
The three Defendants manufactured four kinds of individual products. Two of those kinds were manufactured through subcontractors, including the subcontractor Defendant. The individual products were manufactured for the purpose of sale to one hospital abroad. The intention was that they would be used together in the same procedure at that hospital. [1]
The Supreme Court reversed the lower court’s findings on three claims. Claim 1 consists of two elements. Claim 5 is a dependent claim of Claim 1 and adds two elements. Claim 6 is a dependent claim that refers to Claim 5 and Claim 1 in turn and adds one element. [1]
The lower court, the IP High Court of Korea, found that a product made up of two kinds of the individual products infringes the Claim 1 invention. However, the lower court denied infringement in three respects. They are a product in which another component is combined with that product, the Claim 5 invention, and the Claim 6 invention. The reason was that additional processing and assembly are needed. [1]
The written judgment selects four issues as its Main Issues and Holdings. [1]
- If another component is combined with a product that has all the elements of the Claim 1 invention, does the product cease to infringe?
- Does “provided with” (구비하는) in a claim mean a physically joined state?
- Is it infringement of the Claim 6 invention to manufacture the individual products without assembling them?
- Is a subcontractor that made a component to order released from the presumption of negligence?
The Supreme Court also decided other grounds of appeal. That part is set out under “The parts of the lower judgment that were upheld” below. [1]
What the court held 1: where four circumstances exist, the case is treated as if the product had been manufactured in Korea
The Supreme Court first stated the principle. The exclusive right to work the invention that the patentee of an invention of a product holds is effective only within the territory of the country where the patent right is registered. The Supreme Court called this principle the “principle of territoriality of patent rights” (특허권의 속지주의 원칙). The acts of working that the Supreme Court listed are manufacturing, using, assigning, leasing, importing and the like. [1]
The Supreme Court then stated the exception. Where the circumstances below exist, the case is “exceptionally” treated as if the product working the patented invention had been manufactured in Korea. The Supreme Court stated that treating the case in this way accords with the “substantive protection of patent rights”. [1]
| No. | Circumstance stated in the decision |
|---|---|
| 1 | “All the components or elements” used to work the patented invention are manufactured in Korea. Or a “semi-finished product that has all the main elements”, for which most of the manufacturing stages are complete, is manufactured in Korea |
| 2 | Those components or that semi-finished product are “exported to a single entity”, and processing and assembly at the final stage are planned |
| 3 | That processing and assembly are “extremely minor or simple” (극히 사소하거나 간단) |
| 4 | The manufacturing of all the components or of the semi-finished product alone has reached “a state in which” the function and effect of the invention “can be realized”. The written judgment describes this function and effect as the one that the elements have as an organically combined whole |
The table restates one sentence of the written judgment. The words in quotation marks are the words of the written judgment. [1] The written judgment does not state the third and the fourth separately. It joins them: if the processing and assembly are extremely minor or simple so that the state in the fourth is reached. [1] The division into four is the arrangement of this article.
The Supreme Court found that this case falls under the exception. It found that infringement of the Claim 6 invention is established by the three Defendants’ manufacturing of the individual products alone. The Supreme Court considered the following circumstances. [1]
- By manufacturing the individual products, the three Defendants manufactured all the elements for working the Claim 6 invention.
- The individual products were manufactured from the outset with the intention of selling them to one hospital abroad so that they would be used together in the same procedure.
- What remained was to place another component at the end of one component and fix it there. The specification presented no method of fixing other than one embodiment. The Supreme Court found that a person skilled in the art could select that method appropriately.
- A person skilled in the art can assemble and combine the individual products according to their functions and use them without particular difficulty.
The lower court denied infringement of the Claim 6 invention solely on the ground that additional processing and assembly are required. The Supreme Court stated that this finding erred by misapprehending the legal principle on patent infringement. [1]

What the court held 2: the other three issues
A product with added components infringes if it still contains the elements of the claim as they are
The Supreme Court applied the legal principle of the relationship of use. If a later invention is in a relationship of use with an earlier patented invention, the later invention falls within the scope of the right of the earlier patented invention. [1]
A relationship of use exists where the later invention adds a new technical element to the technical features of the earlier patented invention. The later invention must contain the whole gist of the earlier patented invention and use it as it is. Within the later invention, the earlier patented invention must keep its integrity as an invention. [1]
The Claim 1 invention consists of two elements only. Claim 1 contains no limitation on how any other component added to them is combined. For that reason, the Supreme Court found that a product in which another component is combined with the two elements of Claim 1 also infringes the Claim 1 invention. [1]
“Provided with” does not mean a physical connection
The Supreme Court confirmed the principles of claim interpretation. The scope of protection of a patented invention is determined by what is stated in the claims. In principle, it is not permitted to limit or extend the scope of protection by the description of the invention or the drawings. [1]
The interpretation of the claims is based on the ordinary meaning of the wording. The technical significance that the wording is intended to express is examined by taking into account the description of the invention, the drawings and the like. The interpretation must be objective and reasonable. [1]
Claim 5 recites an element in which one component is “provided with” (구비하는) another component on its inside. The Supreme Court stated that “provided with” ordinarily means being “equipped with” (갖추어진) something. It does not mean that the components must be physically fixed or joined. [1]
The Supreme Court found that a person skilled in the art has no particular technical difficulty in placing the two components in that way and using them. The Supreme Court found that the individual products manufactured by the three Defendants contain the elements of the Claim 5 invention as they are. This covers each element and the organic combination between the elements. [1]
Having made the component to order, and similar circumstances, do not by themselves release a party from the presumption of negligence
Art. 130 of the Patent Act presumes that a person who infringes another person’s patent right or exclusive license was negligent regarding that infringement. [4] The Supreme Court stated that a person who works another person’s patented invention without permission must assert and prove one of the following two things to be released from this presumption. [1]
- Circumstances that justify not having known of the existence of the patent right
- Circumstances that justify having believed that the technology the person works does not fall within the scope of the right of the patented invention
The subcontractor Defendant manufactured one component. The lower court found that this manufacturing was indirect infringement (acts deemed infringement under Art. 127) of the Claim 1 invention. Even so, the lower court found that the presumption of negligence against this company was rebutted. The reason was that it had only made the component at the request of another Defendant. A further reason was that there was no material showing that it knew of the Plaintiff’s patent or sold the component to the public. [1]
The Supreme Court found that the reasons given by the lower court were not sufficient. It is difficult to find that circumstances justifying not having known of the existence of the patent right were asserted and proved. The same applies to circumstances justifying not having known that the component is used only for manufacturing the patented invention. The Supreme Court reversed the part concerning the claim for damages against this company. [1]
The parts of the lower judgment that were upheld
The Supreme Court dismissed the remainder of the Plaintiff’s final appeal and all of the Defendants’ final appeals. The findings of the lower court that were upheld are as follows. [1]
- Two kinds of the individual products are not indirect infringement of the Claim 1 and Claim 5 inventions.
- There was a product in which yet another component was added to the product that infringes the Claim 1 invention. Infringement of the Claim 14 and Claim 15 inventions is not established by the individual elements of that product alone.
- It cannot be found that the three Defendants manufactured a component of one shape for business purposes.
- The amount of damage caused by infringement of the Claim 1 invention is set as reasonable damages under Art. 128(7) of the Patent Act.
- The three Defendants infringed the Claim 1 invention. The three Defendants and the subcontractor Defendant indirectly infringed the Claim 1 invention by manufacturing one component.
On these parts, the Supreme Court stated only that there was no error in the lower court’s findings. The written judgment does not state why infringement of the Claim 14 and Claim 15 inventions was not established. [1] The manufacturing of the individual products was not found to be infringement for every claim.
What the court did not decide
This decision did not decide whether the act of exporting is itself infringement. What the Supreme Court found to be infringement is the act of manufacturing the individual products in Korea. [1] Art. 2, subparagraph 3 (a) of the Patent Act in force on the date of the decision did not list exporting as an act of working. [5]
This decision did not set the standard for the exception in numbers. The written judgment contains no general definition of how much is meant by “most of the manufacturing stages”, “main elements” or “extremely minor or simple”. [1]
The case where the components are exported separately to several entities is also not in the written judgment. The circumstance that the decision states is export “to a single entity”. [1]
The Supreme Court did not newly state a legal principle on indirect infringement. The lower court found that some of the individual products are not indirect infringement of the Claim 1 and Claim 5 inventions. The Supreme Court stated only that there was no error in that finding. [1]
The Supreme Court did not set the amount of damage for the reversed parts. The Supreme Court remanded the case to the IP High Court of Korea for those parts to be heard and decided again. [1] The result after the remand could not be confirmed.
Before and after this decision: it stands between a 2015 decision and a 2025 decision
This decision is not an en banc decision. The written judgment does not say that it overrules an earlier precedent. No Reference Cases are given for Main Issues and Holdings [3]. [1]
| Decision | What it held |
|---|---|
| Supreme Court Decision 2014Da42110 Decided July 23, 2015 | In “a product used exclusively for manufacturing such product” in Art. 127, subparagraph 1 of the Patent Act, “manufacturing” means manufacturing in Korea. If that manufacturing takes place outside Korea, indirect infringement cannot be established even if the acts at the preceding stage take place in Korea [2] |
| Supreme Court Decision 2019Da222782, 222799 Decided October 17, 2019 | Where four circumstances exist, the case is exceptionally treated as if the product working the patented invention had been manufactured in Korea [1] |
| Supreme Court Decision 2025Da202970 Decided May 15, 2025 | It restated the standard of the 2019 decision. Whether a case falls under it must be judged “strictly”. It also restated the legal principle on indirect infringement of the 2015 decision [3] |
How it differs from the 2015 decision
The 2015 decision concerned semi-finished products that were manufactured in Korea and exported, and were manufactured into finished products outside Korea. Those semi-finished products lacked some of the elements of the claim. The Supreme Court accepted the lower court’s finding that the manufacturing of the semi-finished products is not direct infringement. Indirect infringement was not established either. [2]
In the 2019 decision, the three Defendants manufactured all the elements for working the claim. The Supreme Court found that the manufacturing alone brought about, in Korea, a state in which the function and effect can be realized. [1] The written judgment of the 2019 decision does not cite the 2015 decision. [1]
The two decisions also answered different questions. The 2015 decision is a decision on “acts deemed infringement” under Art. 127, subparagraph 1, that is, on indirect infringement. [2] The exception in the 2019 decision concerns the case that is treated as if the product working the invention had been manufactured in Korea. The Reference Provisions that the 2019 decision attaches to Main Issues and Holdings [3] are Art. 94 and Art. 127, subparagraph 1. [1] The lower court in the 2025 decision used the standard of the 2019 decision to decide direct infringement. [3]
The 2025 decision contains the word “strictly”
Supreme Court Decision 2025Da202970 Decided May 15, 2025 cited the 2019 decision as a Reference Case. The 2025 decision states the four circumstances of the 2019 decision in the same wording. [3]
The 2025 decision contains a sentence that is not in the 2019 decision. The sentence says that whether a case falls under the exception must be judged strictly, taking into account the principle of territoriality of patent rights and the “all elements rule” (구성요소 완비의 원칙). [3] The words “all elements rule” and “strictly” (엄격하게) do not appear in the written judgment of the 2019 decision. [1] The words that state the conclusion also differ. The 2019 decision says that “treating” the case “exceptionally” as if the product had been manufactured accords with the substantive protection of patent rights. The 2025 decision says that the case “may be treated” as if the product had been manufactured. [1] [3]
In the 2025 decision, the exception was not accepted. The defendant manufactured several kinds of bulk solution. The final stage was a step of mixing those bulk solutions to make a composition. The lower court found that the mixing conditions could have a considerable influence on realizing the composition. For that reason, the lower court found that the step could not be regarded as extremely minor or simple. [3]
The lower court also found that the manufacturing of the bulk solutions alone could not be said to have reached a state in which the function and effect of the invention can be realized. The Supreme Court stated that there was no error in the lower court’s findings. [3]
In the 2025 decision, indirect infringement was not established either. The lower court denied indirect infringement on the ground that all the bulk solutions were exported and manufactured into finished products outside Korea. The Supreme Court stated that there was no error in this finding either. [3]
Other decisions that cite this decision
On 9 October 2026, a case search of the Ministry of Government Legislation (법제처) returned 8 decisions, other than this decision, in which the case number of this decision appears in the text. [7] Five of them are Supreme Court decisions. The remaining three are decisions of the IP High Court of Korea. They are Patent Court Decision 2023Na10914 Decided December 3, 2024, Patent Court Decision 2023Heo10613 Decided November 30, 2023, and Patent Court Decision 2022Heo4826 Decided November 30, 2023. [7]
| Decision | Issue on which it cites this decision |
|---|---|
| Supreme Court Decision 2018Hu12202 Decided April 9, 2020 | Claim interpretation |
| Supreme Court Decision 2021Da217011 Decided June 30, 2021 | Claim interpretation |
| Supreme Court Decision 2023Da289508 Decided October 31, 2024 | Relationship of use |
| Supreme Court Decision 2025Da202970 Decided May 15, 2025 | Exception to territoriality, claim interpretation |
| Supreme Court en banc Decision 2021Du59908 Decided September 18, 2025 | A Dissenting Opinion cites it on the principle of territoriality |
Of the five decisions in the table, the one read in full is Decision 2025Da202970. For the other four, the passages that cite this decision were read. [3] [7] En banc Decision 2021Du59908 is a tax case. [7]
In the same search, the phrase “extremely minor or simple” (극히 사소하거나 간단) appeared in the text of 3 decisions. They are this decision, Decision 2025Da202970, and its lower judgment, Patent Court Decision 2023Na10914 Decided December 3, 2024. [7] The same search returned no decision that overruled the standard of this decision.
Has the law that the decision applied changed since then?
The written judgment cites the provisions of the Patent Act without the marker “former” (구). [1] The written judgment does not state which version of the Patent Act the decision applied. [1] The Patent Act in force on the date of the decision is the version in force from 9 July 2019 (Act No. 16208). [5] The table below compares that version with the current Patent Act (Act No. 21134), provision by provision. [4] [5]
| Provision | Difference between the version on the date of the decision and the current version | Amending Act and enforcement date |
|---|---|---|
| Art. 2, subparagraph 3 (a) and (c) (working) | “Exporting” was added to the acts of working | Act No. 20700, in force from 22 July 2025 |
| Art. 2, subparagraph 3 (b) (working) | “Offering the use of the method” was added | Act No. 16804, in force from 11 March 2020 |
| Art. 94 (effects of patents) | The former provision became paragraph (1) and paragraph (2) was newly inserted. The wording of paragraph (1) is the same as before | Act No. 16804, in force from 11 March 2020 |
| Art. 127, subparagraphs 1 and 2 (acts deemed infringement) | “Exporting” was added to the acts deemed infringement | Act No. 20700, in force from 22 July 2025 |
| Art. 128(2) and (3) (amount of damage) | Paragraph (2) was amended and paragraph (3) was deleted | Act No. 17422, in force from 10 December 2020 |
| Art. 128(8) (cap on the damages) | “Three times” was changed to “five times” | Act No. 20322, in force from 21 August 2024 |
| Art. 97, Art. 98, Art. 126, Art. 130 | The wording is the same | Not applicable |
The Act numbers and enforcement dates in the table were read from the header and the Addenda of each version. [6]
Art. 128(8) is a paragraph that first appeared in the version on the date of the decision. Act No. 16208 newly inserted paragraphs (8) and (9) and entered into force on 9 July 2019. Art. 3 of the Addenda to Act No. 16208 provides that the two paragraphs apply beginning with the first violation that occurs after that Act enters into force. [6] The lower judgment was decided on 19 February 2019, before that enforcement date. [1] The version in force on that day is the version in force from 18 October 2018 (Act No. 15582). Among the provisions in the table above, the only one that differs between that version and the version in force from 9 July 2019 is Art. 128. In paragraph (5), “ordinarily” (통상적으로) was changed to “reasonably” (합리적으로), and paragraphs (8) and (9) were newly inserted. [5] [6]
The Addenda to Act No. 16804 set only the enforcement date. They contain no applicability provision or transitional measure for Art. 2, subparagraph 3 (b) or Art. 94(2). [6]
Act No. 20700 was promulgated on 21 January 2025. Art. 1 of the Addenda to this Act sets the enforcement date as the date six months after the date of its promulgation. Art. 2 of the Addenda is an applicability provision on the extension of the term of a patent right. These Addenda contain no applicability provision or transitional measure for the amended provisions of Art. 2 and Art. 127. [6]
The amendments to Art. 128 have applicability provisions. Art. 2 of the Addenda to Act No. 17422 is one of them. The amended provisions of Art. 128 apply beginning with the first case in which damages are claimed after that Act enters into force. Art. 2 of the Addenda to Act No. 20322 provides that the amended provision of Art. 128(8) applies beginning with violations that occur on or after the date on which that Act enters into force. [6]
“Manufacturing” is an act of working under Art. 2, subparagraph 3 (a) in both the version on the date of the decision and the current version. [4] [5] The current Art. 127, subparagraph 1 also still has the wording “a product used exclusively for manufacturing such product”. [4]
The 2019 decision and the 2025 decision were both decided before 22 July 2025. [1] [3] On 9 October 2026, a case search of the Ministry of Government Legislation did not find a Supreme Court decision that interprets Art. 2 and Art. 127 as amended to include exporting.
The Act on Partial Amendment to the Patent Act that was promulgated on 15 September 2026 (Act No. 21955) enters into force on 16 March 2027. In that version, the wording of the provisions in the table above is the same as in the current version. [6]
How exporting became an act of working, and the remedies, are covered in “Is exporting an infringing act in Korea?”.
What changes in practice
The following is the opinion of the firm. The conclusion in an individual case depends on the facts, so please confirm it with your agent.
- In general, for a product whose components are made in Korea and which is completed abroad, we suggest checking the final step first. The 2019 decision and the 2025 decision both examined the content of the final step in detail.
- We suggest that patentees collect evidence separately for each of the four circumstances. The first questions are whether all the elements are manufactured in Korea and whether they go to a single entity. The content of the final processing and assembly, and whether the function and effect can be realized before that, are also examined.
- When drafting claims for a Korean application, we suggest limiting the connection between elements only as far as necessary. In this decision, “provided with” was interpreted as not meaning a physical connection.
- For a product that is traded in the form of a set of components or a kit, a claim directed to that form is worth considering. The 2025 decision stated that the exception must be judged strictly.
- We suggest that Korean manufacturers that make components to order check patents at the stage of receiving the order. In this decision, the Supreme Court found that the reasons given by the lower court, such as having made the component on request, do not by themselves rebut the presumption of negligence.
- For acts on or after 22 July 2025, we suggest also reviewing Art. 2, subparagraph 3 and Art. 127, which now list exporting.
How Korea differs
The United States patent statute has a provision that directly governs the supply of components abroad. It is 35 U.S.C. § 271(f). [8]
| Item | Korea | United States |
|---|---|---|
| Basis | An exception established by a Supreme Court decision [1] | A statutory provision, 35 U.S.C. § 271(f) [8] |
| Subject | All the components or elements manufactured in Korea, or a semi-finished product that has all the main elements [1] | Under (f)(1), all or a substantial portion of the components. Under (f)(2), a component that is especially made or especially adapted for use in the invention and is not a staple article suitable for substantial noninfringing use. Under both paragraphs, the components must be uncombined in whole or in part [8] |
| Act | Manufacturing in Korea [1] | Supplying, or causing to be supplied, in or from the United States [8] |
| Combination abroad | The processing and assembly at the final stage must be extremely minor or simple [1] | The combination must be in a manner that would infringe the patent if it occurred within the United States [8] |
§ 271(f)(1) requires that the supply be made in a manner that actively induces the combination outside the United States. § 271(f)(2) requires knowledge and intent on the part of the supplier. [8] The Korean 2019 decision took into account the circumstance that the individual products were manufactured with the intention that they be used together. [1]
Art. 127 of the Korean Patent Act has no wording on combination outside Korea. [4] The United States provision was read in the United States Code, 2024 Edition. [8] United States court decisions were not read.
FAQ
Is it not infringement of a Korean patent to make only components in Korea and export them?
That cannot be concluded. The Supreme Court held that, where four circumstances exist, the case is exceptionally treated as if the product working the invention had been manufactured in Korea. [1] The 2025 decision stated that whether a case falls under this exception must be judged strictly. [3]
Did this decision find exporting to be infringement?
No. What the Supreme Court found to be infringement is the act of manufacturing the individual products in Korea. [1] Exporting has been an act of working under Art. 2, subparagraph 3 (a) of the Patent Act since 22 July 2025. [4] [6]
What if the final assembly done abroad is not simple?
In the 2025 decision, the exception was not accepted. The lower court’s finding that the mixing step at the final stage could not be regarded as extremely minor or simple was upheld. [3]
Is this decision still valid?
On 9 October 2026, a case search of the Ministry of Government Legislation returned no decision that overruled this decision. The Supreme Court cited this decision as a Reference Case in its decision of 15 May 2025. [3] [7]
Is a company that made components as ordered also liable for damages?
The lower court found that the presumption of negligence was rebutted, for reasons such as that the company had only made the component at the request of another Defendant. The Supreme Court found the reasons given by the lower court insufficient and reversed that part. [1] The Supreme Court did not decide that company’s liability for damages or the amount of damage. [1]
How DEFINE IP Law Firm handles this
When DEFINE IP Law Firm begins an infringement review, we separate the acts of the other party by the country in which they take place. For a product whose components are manufactured in Korea and which is completed abroad, we check the content of the final step separately. We do not present as the standard of a decision anything that is not in the written judgment. For questions about components manufactured in Korea for export and patent infringement, please write to contact@defineip.kr.
Sources
- Supreme Court Decision 2019Da222782, 222799 Decided October 17, 2019 (대법원 2019. 10. 17. 선고 2019다222782, 222799 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2019다222782) (verified 2026-10-09)
- Supreme Court Decision 2014Da42110 Decided July 23, 2015 (대법원 2015. 7. 23. 선고 2014다42110 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2014다42110) (verified 2026-10-09)
- Supreme Court Decision 2025Da202970 Decided May 15, 2025 (대법원 2025. 5. 15. 선고 2025다202970 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2025다202970) (verified 2026-10-09)
- Patent Act (특허법), Act No. 21134, in force from 2025-11-11. Art. 2, Art. 94, Art. 97, Art. 98, Art. 126, Art. 127, Art. 128, Art. 130. https://www.law.go.kr/법령/특허법 (verified 2026-10-09)
- Patent Act (특허법), Act No. 16208, in force from 2019-07-09 (the version in force on the date of the decision) and Patent Act, Act No. 15582, in force from 2018-10-18 (the version in force on the date of the lower judgment). Art. 2, Art. 94, Art. 97, Art. 98, Art. 126, Art. 127, Art. 128, Art. 130. History of https://www.law.go.kr/법령/특허법 (verified 2026-10-09)
- Headers and Addenda of the Acts amending the Patent Act (특허법): Act No. 16208 (promulgated on 2019-01-08, in force from 2019-07-09), Addenda, Art. 1 and Art. 3; Act No. 16804 (promulgated on 2019-12-10, in force from 2020-03-11), Addenda; Act No. 17422 (promulgated on 2020-06-09, in force from 2020-12-10), Addenda, Art. 1 and Art. 2; Act No. 20322 (promulgated on 2024-02-20, in force from 2024-08-21), Addenda, Art. 1 and Art. 2; Act No. 20700 (promulgated on 2025-01-21, in force from 2025-07-22), Addenda, Art. 1 and Art. 2; Act No. 21955 (promulgated on 2026-09-15, scheduled to enter into force on 2027-03-16). History of https://www.law.go.kr/법령/특허법 (verified 2026-10-09)
- Case search of the Korean Law Information Center of the Ministry of Government Legislation (법제처 국가법령정보) (full-text searches for “2019다222782” and “극히 사소하거나 간단”) and the citing passages of the decisions found: Supreme Court Decision 2018Hu12202 Decided April 9, 2020 (대법원 2020. 4. 9. 선고 2018후12202 판결), Supreme Court Decision 2021Da217011 Decided June 30, 2021 (대법원 2021. 6. 30. 선고 2021다217011 판결), Supreme Court Decision 2023Da289508 Decided October 31, 2024 (대법원 2024. 10. 31. 선고 2023다289508 판결), Supreme Court en banc Decision 2021Du59908 Decided September 18, 2025 (대법원 2025. 9. 18. 선고 2021두59908 전원합의체 판결), Patent Court Decision 2023Na10914 Decided December 3, 2024 (특허법원 2024. 12. 3. 선고 2023나10914 판결), Patent Court Decision 2023Heo10613 Decided November 30, 2023 (특허법원 2023. 11. 30. 선고 2023허10613 판결), Patent Court Decision 2022Heo4826 Decided November 30, 2023 (특허법원 2023. 11. 30. 선고 2022허4826 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/ (verified 2026-10-09)
- U.S. Government Publishing Office, 35 U.S.C. § 271, United States Code 2024 Edition. https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCODE-2024-title35/html/USCODE-2024-title35-partIII-chap28-sec271.htm (verified 2026-10-09)