← 글 목록← All articles

Supreme Court en banc Decision 2016Hu2522 Decided January 22, 2020: what happens when a correction becomes final and conclusive after closure of pleadings?

Brief summary

  • The Supreme Court of Korea held that no grounds for retrial arise even if a trial decision for correction (정정심결) becomes final and conclusive after closure of pleadings of fact-finding proceedings. This means that the lower judgment, which was decided on the specification before correction, has no grounds for retrial under the Civil Procedure Act (민사소송법), Art. 451(1), subparagraph 8. [1]
  • The Supreme Court overruled the earlier decisions that had treated a trial decision for correction becoming final and conclusive as grounds for retrial. This legal principle also applies to an action requesting revocation of a decision rendered by the Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board (IPTAB) (legal proceedings against trial rulings) (심결취소소송) in a trial to confirm the scope of a right (권리범위확인심판), and to civil litigation arising from patent infringement. [1]
  • The patentee in this case did not prevail on the ground of appeal based on the trial decision for correction. However, the Supreme Court found that the inventive step of the claims before correction is not denied, and reversed the lower judgment. [1]

Last verified

The case

Item Details
Court Supreme Court of Korea
Date of decision 22 January 2020
Case number 2016Hu2522
Case name Invalidation of Registration (Patent)
Lower court Patent Court Decision 2016Heo4542 Decided October 21, 2016
Result The lower judgment is reversed, and the case is remanded to the Intellectual Property High Court of Korea (Patent Court of Korea) (특허법원)
En banc or not En banc decision. There is a Concurring Opinion by two Justices on ground of appeal No. 1, and an Opinion concurring with the Majority Opinion by one Justice
Reference Provisions (as stated in the decision) Administrative Litigation Act (행정소송법), Art. 8(2), Civil Procedure Act, Art. 451(1), subparagraph 8, Patent Act (특허법), Art. 136 and Art. 137, Patent Act, Art. 29(2)

The content of this table is taken from the written judgment. [1]

The issue: can a trial decision for correction that becomes final and conclusive during the final appeal overturn the lower judgment?

There are two issues. The first is whether a trial decision for correction that became final and conclusive after closure of pleadings of fact-finding proceedings constitutes grounds for retrial of the lower judgment. The second is whether the lower court’s determination on inventive step is correct. This article focuses on the first issue. [1]

The course of the case, as stated in the written judgment, is as follows. [1]

Date What happened
24 December 2015 The petitioner filed a petition for a trial for invalidation of the registration, arguing that inventive step is denied
20 May 2016 The IPTAB (특허심판원) dismissed the petition for trial on the ground that inventive step is not denied
22 June 2016 The petitioner filed an action with the IP High Court of Korea seeking revocation of the trial decision
21 October 2016 The IP High Court of Korea revoked the trial decision, finding that the inventive step of claims 1, 3 and 4 is denied
4 November 2016 The patentee filed a final appeal
28 November 2016 The patentee filed a petition for a trial for correction (정정심판) that limits the position of one element of claim 1
8 February 2017 The IPTAB rendered a trial decision correcting claim 1 to that effect. The trial decision for correction was served on the patentee around that time
22 January 2020 The Supreme Court rendered its decision

The Majority Opinion took the view that a trial decision for correction that allows the correction becomes final and conclusive when it is served on the patentee who filed the petition for the trial for correction. The reason is that there is no separate appeal procedure against such a trial decision for correction. [1]

In the final appeal, the patentee put forward, as a ground of appeal, the fact that the trial decision for correction had become final and conclusive. Earlier Supreme Court decisions had held that, in such a case, the lower judgment has grounds for retrial. The 2001 decision reversed a lower judgment that had determined invalidity on the patented invention before correction. It did not decide the remaining grounds of appeal. [7]

The provision that sets the grounds for retrial is the Civil Procedure Act, Art. 451(1), subparagraph 8. This subparagraph makes it grounds for retrial when a judgment or an administrative disposition on which the judgment was based has been altered by a different judgment or administrative disposition. [11] The Administrative Litigation Act, Art. 8(2) applies the provisions of the Court Organization Act (법원조직법), the Civil Procedure Act and the Civil Execution Act (민사집행법) mutatis mutandis to matters for which the Administrative Litigation Act has no special provision. [12] The Supreme Court stated that, under this provision, the Civil Procedure Act, Art. 451(1), subparagraph 8 applies mutatis mutandis to a revocation action. [1]

What the court held 1: a trial decision for correction that becomes final and conclusive after closure of pleadings does not constitute grounds for retrial

The Majority Opinion first fixed the meaning of subparagraph 8. Subparagraph 8 does not refer to the case where the administrative disposition that is itself the subject of examination and determination in the judgment is later altered. Subparagraph 8 refers to the case where an administrative disposition that is legally binding on the final and conclusive judgment has been altered. The same applies where an administrative disposition that served as material for fact-finding in the final and conclusive judgment has been altered. The alteration must be “conclusive and retroactive”. [1]

The Majority Opinion reached its conclusion under this standard. In a revocation action against a trial decision in a trial for invalidation of a patent (특허무효심판), a trial decision for correction sometimes becomes final and conclusive after closure of pleadings of fact-finding proceedings. In that case too, the lower judgment decided on the specification or drawings before correction has no grounds for retrial under subparagraph 8. [1]

The Majority Opinion gave three reasons. [1]

First, the decision to grant (특허결정) is the “subject to be examined and determined” in a revocation action. The decision to grant is not an administrative disposition on which the judgment was based. Under the Patent Act, Art. 186(6), an action on a matter for which a petition for trial may be filed may not be filed unless it is against a trial decision. An action on a matter for which a request for revocation of a granted patent (특허취소신청) may be filed must likewise be against a decision to revoke the patent. [8] The Majority Opinion explained that, for this reason, a party cannot make the decision to grant itself the subject of an action. [1]

Second, even when a trial decision for correction becomes final and conclusive, it cannot be concluded that the content of the patented invention has been conclusively altered. An interested party or an examiner may file a petition for a trial to invalidate corrections (정정의 무효심판) where the correction violates the specified provisions (Patent Act, Art. 137(1)). Those provisions are the subparagraphs of Art. 136(1) and Art. 136(3) through (5). Paragraphs (3) through (5) include the cases where they apply mutatis mutandis under Art. 132-3(3) or Art. 133-2(4). When a trial decision invalidating a correction becomes final and conclusive, that correction is deemed never to have existed (Art. 137(5)). [8] The Majority Opinion took the view that whether the patent under the specification before correction is invalid still remains a subject of dispute. [1]

The Patent Act, Art. 136(10) provides for the effect when a trial decision for correction becomes final and conclusive. The patent application, the laying-open of the application, the decision to grant or the trial decision, and the registration of the grant of a patent (registration of establishment of a patent right) are deemed to have been made according to the specification or drawings after correction. [8] The Majority Opinion read the purport of this provision as follows. The Majority Opinion stated that it is difficult to interpret this provision as retroactively changing all legal relationships that arose under the specification before correction. [1]

Third, the patentee has an opportunity to correct before closure of pleadings of fact-finding proceedings. In the trial for invalidation of a patent, the patentee can respond to the invalidity argument by a request for correction (정정청구). In the fact-finding proceedings of the revocation action against that trial decision, the patentee can respond by a petition for a trial for correction. The Majority Opinion did not allow a party to contest the determination of the fact-finding court on the basis of a trial decision for correction that became final and conclusive after closure of pleadings. The reason is that this significantly delays the litigation proceedings and the resolution of the dispute. [1]

What the court of final appeal reviews, by the timing of the trial decision for correction

What the court held 2: the same applies to scope confirmation cases, patent infringement litigation and requests for correction

The Majority Opinion also stated the other proceedings to which this legal principle applies. [1]

Proceedings What the Majority Opinion stated
Revocation action against a trial decision in a trial for invalidation of a patent Even if a trial decision for correction becomes final and conclusive after closure of pleadings of fact-finding proceedings, the lower judgment has no grounds for retrial
Revocation action against a trial decision in a trial to confirm the scope of a right The same legal principle applies as it is
Civil litigation arising from patent infringement The same legal principle applies as it is
Request for correction within a trial for invalidation of a patent or a trial to invalidate corrections The same legal principle applies also where the trial decision on the request for correction has become final and conclusive

The explanation on patent infringement litigation needs to be read separately. In litigation seeking an injunction against infringement or damages, the other party sometimes raises a defense pleading an abuse of right. It is a defense that it is obvious that the patent will be invalidated. The Majority Opinion stated that the patentee can counter this defense with a “re-plea” (재항변). The patentee asserts the circumstance that the ground for invalidation has been resolved, or can be resolved, by a petition for a trial for correction or a request for correction. [1]

The Majority Opinion also did not allow the patentee to contest belatedly in patent infringement litigation. The phrase in the written judgment is “although the final judgment has become final and conclusive, or the patentee did not submit a re-plea of correction before that”. The Majority Opinion stated that, even so, contesting the determination of the fact-finding court on the ground that a trial decision for correction became final and conclusive after closure of pleadings of fact-finding proceedings is not allowed. [1]

A request for correction is a correction made within a trial for invalidation of a patent or a trial to invalidate corrections (Patent Act, Art. 133-2(1) and Art. 137(3)). The respondent in that trial may file a request for correction within the designated period (specified period). [8] The Patent Act, Art. 132-3(1) also provides for a request for correction in the proceedings on a request for revocation of a granted patent. [8] The Majority Opinion named the request for correction in a trial for invalidation of a patent and in a trial to invalidate corrections, and did not name the request for correction in the proceedings on a request for revocation of a granted patent. [1] The Majority Opinion explained that the trial on a request for correction is examined together in the trial for invalidation of a patent. There are cases where the trial decision on a request for correction becomes final and conclusive in a trial for invalidation of a patent that proceeded separately from the revocation action. The Majority Opinion stated that, in that case too, a judgment decided on the specification before correction has no grounds for retrial. [1]

What the court held 3: the lower judgment in this case was reversed because of its determination on inventive step

The Supreme Court did not accept the patentee’s first ground of appeal. It stated that, even though a trial decision for correction became final and conclusive while the final appeal was pending, this does not constitute grounds for retrial. The Supreme Court added two points. A trial decision for correction becoming final and conclusive after closure of pleadings is an argument newly raised in the final appeal. Requirements for patentability such as inventive step are not matters to be investigated ex officio. [1]

The Supreme Court accepted the second ground of appeal. In determining inventive step, one must not judge with hindsight on the premise that the technology disclosed in the specification of that invention is known. The Supreme Court found that, in order to combine the prior art, the structure of the prior art would have to be changed greatly. It stated that no such suggestion and motivation are presented in the prior art. The Supreme Court determined that the inventive step of claim 1 is not denied. It determined that the same applies to claims 3 and 4, which are dependent claims. [1]

What the Supreme Court determined is the claims before correction. The Opinion concurring with the Majority Opinion described this case as one where the lower court’s substantive determination on the specification before correction was wrong. [1] The standard for determining inventive step is covered in “What is the inventive step standard under Article 29(2) of the Korean Patent Act?“.

The Concurring Opinion and the Opinion concurring with the Majority Opinion

Two Justices gave a Concurring Opinion. The Concurring Opinion took the view that, when a trial decision for correction becomes final and conclusive after closure of pleadings, the lower judgment has grounds for retrial. Its conclusion that the lower judgment must be reversed and the case remanded is the same as that of the Majority Opinion. What differs is the reasoning. [1]

The arguments of the Concurring Opinion are as follows. [1]

  • The Concurring Opinion took the view that, under the Patent Act, Art. 136(10), the effect of a trial decision for correction is retroactive to the time of filing of the patent application. The Concurring Opinion stated that the interpretation of the Majority Opinion is contrary to this provision.
  • There are patentees who obtained a trial decision upholding the patent and became the defendant in a revocation action. The Concurring Opinion stated that such a patentee may realize the need for a correction only because of evidence or an argument on a ground for invalidation newly produced during the pleadings.
  • The fact-finding court may close the pleadings without waiting for the result of the trial for correction. The Concurring Opinion stated that the patentee then loses the opportunity to be judged on the corrected specification.

One Justice gave an Opinion concurring with the Majority Opinion. The following is the content of that opinion and is not a standard held by the Majority Opinion. [1]

  • Under the earlier precedents, a patentee who lost in the fact-finding proceedings obtained a trial decision for correction and asserted it as a ground of appeal. That opinion took the view that this damaged legal stability and trust in the patent litigation system.
  • There are cases where a trial decision for correction becomes final and conclusive during the final appeal against a judgment of the IP High Court of Korea that upheld a trial decision for invalidation of a patent. That opinion took the view that, if the Supreme Court dismisses the final appeal, the invalidity of that patent becomes final and conclusive regardless of whether there was a correction.
  • That opinion stated that the fact-finding court must give the patentee an adequate opportunity for correction while the litigation is in progress.
  • There are cases where the patentee files a petition for a trial for correction before closure of pleadings and asks the court to decide on the specification after correction. That opinion stated that the fact-finding court then needs to decide whether to close the pleadings by considering various circumstances together.

That opinion named five circumstances. [1]

  • The specific content of the grounds for correction
  • Whether the correction, if accepted, affects the conclusion of the revocation action
  • The history of past corrections
  • Whether an opportunity to correct was secured
  • Whether the main purpose of filing the petition for the trial for correction is to delay the litigation

What the court did not decide

The Supreme Court did not decide whether the claims after correction have a ground for invalidation. What the Supreme Court determined as to inventive step is claims 1, 3 and 4 before correction. [1]

The Supreme Court remanded the case to the IP High Court of Korea. The Opinion concurring with the Majority Opinion wrote that the lower court after the remand will examine the case again on the specification after correction. [1] The result after the remand could not be confirmed.

The Majority Opinion did not determine whether the fact-finding court must wait for the result of the trial for correction. The circumstances relating to whether to close the pleadings appear only in the Opinion concurring with the Majority Opinion. [1]

Before and after this decision: it overruled earlier decisions, and later decisions follow this standard

The decisions overruled

The Supreme Court stated that it overrules five decisions and other decisions to the same effect. The scope of the overruling is “the extent they are inconsistent” with the view of this decision. [1]

Decision overruled Type of case
Supreme Court Decision 99Hu598 Decided October 12, 2001 Revocation action
Supreme Court Decision 2007Hu852 Decided July 24, 2008 Revocation action
Supreme Court Decision 2010Hu36 Decided September 9, 2010 Revocation action
Supreme Court Decision 2000Da69194 Decided October 28, 2004 Civil litigation arising from patent infringement
Supreme Court Decision 2004Hu3133 Decided February 24, 2006 Case where the trial decision on a request for correction in a trial for invalidation of a patent became final and conclusive

The classification in the table is as stated in the 2020 en banc decision. [1] The full texts of the 2001, 2008 and 2004 decisions were read. All three decisions reversed the lower judgment on the ground that a trial decision for correction had become final and conclusive. [7] The full texts of the 2010 and 2006 decisions could not be found in the case materials of the Ministry of Government Legislation (법제처).

Later decisions

The case search of the Ministry of Government Legislation did not return any decision that changed this standard (searched on 9 October 2026). The Supreme Court cited this decision in later cases.

Decision Case Determination
Supreme Court Decision 2016Hu2546 Decided April 29, 2020 Confirmation of the Scope of Rights (Patent) Held that, even if a trial decision for correction becomes final and conclusive after closure of pleadings in the lower court, the lower judgment has no grounds for retrial [2]
Supreme Court Decision 2017Hu2055 Decided November 26, 2020 Invalidation of Registration (Patent) Held that a trial decision for correction becoming final and conclusive cannot be asserted as a ground of appeal. Held that the court of final appeal must determine inventive step on the specification before correction [3]
Supreme Court Decision 2017Da231829 Decided January 14, 2021 Injunction against Infringement on Patent Rights, etc. A case where the trial decision on a request for correction in a trial for invalidation became final and conclusive after closure of pleadings in the patent infringement litigation. Held that the court of final appeal must decide on the basis of the specification before correction [4]
Supreme Court Decision 2019Hu10296 Decided December 30, 2021 Invalidation of Registration (Patent) Applied the same standard as the November 2020 decision [5]
Supreme Court Decision 2019Hu10456 Decided June 16, 2022 Invalidation of Registration (Patent) Applied the same standard. The petition for a trial for correction in this case was withdrawn [6]

The sentence “cannot be asserted as a ground of appeal” appears in the November 2020 decision. The en banc decision stated that it does not constitute grounds for retrial, and that a trial decision for correction becoming final and conclusive is an argument newly raised in the final appeal. [1] [3]

The November 2020 decision also wrote where a correction that became final and conclusive after closure of pleadings is dealt with. The lower judgment in that case was a judgment that revoked a trial decision of the IPTAB. Dismissing the final appeal, the Supreme Court wrote that the lower judgment becomes final and conclusive as it is. It then wrote that the IPTAB will proceed with its examination on the claims after correction. [3] The Patent Act, Art. 189(2) provides that, when a judgment revoking a trial decision becomes final and conclusive, the administrative patent judges examine the case again and render a trial decision. [8]

Has the law that the decision applied changed since then?

The wording of the Patent Act, Art. 136(10), which the decision cited, is the same today. The amendment and insertion tags attached to the paragraphs of the current Art. 136 carry two dates: 29 February 2016 and 1 October 2025. The tag dated after the decision was rendered is that of 1 October 2025, and it appears only in paragraphs (12) and (13). Those two paragraphs provide for notification by the President of the Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board and publication in the Patent Gazette. [8] The current Art. 132-3, Art. 133-2, Art. 137, Art. 186 and Art. 189 carry no amendment tag dated after the decision was rendered. [8] The same holds for the Patent Act that enters into force on 16 March 2027 (Act No. 21955). The wording of Art. 132-3, Art. 133-2, Art. 136, Art. 137, Art. 186 and Art. 189 is not changed by that amendment. [10]

The petition for the trial for correction in this case was filed on 28 November 2016. [1] In the Patent Act in force on that day, the same wording was in Art. 136(8). [9] Act No. 14035 moved the paragraph number. This Act was promulgated on 29 February 2016 and entered into force on 1 March 2017. [8] The Supreme Court cited Art. 136(10) without the label “former”. [1]

Act No. 14035 also amended the period during which a petition for a trial for correction cannot be filed. The proviso to Art. 136(1) before the amendment named only one case. It is the case where a trial for invalidation of the patent or a trial to invalidate corrections is pending before the IPTAB. [9] The current Art. 136(2) sets the periods during which a petition cannot be filed in two subparagraphs and places a proviso in subparagraph 1. [8]

Current Art. 136(2) Content
Subparagraph 1, main clause Period during which a petition cannot be filed: the period from the time when a request for revocation of a granted patent is pending before the IPTAB until the decision on it becomes final and conclusive
Subparagraph 1, proviso If an action against a trial decision in a trial for invalidation of a patent or a trial decision in a trial to invalidate corrections is pending before the IP High Court of Korea, a petition for a trial for correction may be filed no later than the date on which the pleadings are closed at the IP High Court of Korea. Where the judgment is rendered without pleadings, no later than the date on which the judgment is rendered
Subparagraph 2 Period during which a petition cannot be filed: the period during which a trial for invalidation of a patent or a trial to invalidate corrections is pending before the IPTAB

The proviso is attached to subparagraph 1. The period in subparagraph 1 runs from the time when a request for revocation of a granted patent is pending before the IPTAB until the decision on it becomes final and conclusive. [8]

The Addenda of Act No. 14035 contain no applicability provision on Art. 136(2). Art. 12 of the Addenda deals only with the amended provisions of Art. 136(8) and (9). Those two amended provisions apply from trials for correction for which a petition is filed on or after the date on which that Act entered into force. [8]

Even after Act No. 14035 entered into force, there are cases in which a petition for a trial for correction was filed after closure of pleadings in the lower court. In the case of the December 2021 decision, the petition for the trial for correction was filed on 27 March 2019, after closure of pleadings in the lower court. The trial decision for correction was rendered on 23 April 2019 and became final and conclusive around that time. The Supreme Court stated that inventive step must be determined on the claims before the trial decision for correction became final and conclusive. [5]

The requirements and procedure for correction are covered in “How can a granted Korean patent be corrected?”. The trial for invalidation is covered in “How does a trial for invalidation work in Korea?“. The revocation action is covered in “How are trial decisions appealed to the Intellectual Property High Court of Korea (Patent Court of Korea)?”.

What changes in practice

The following is the opinion of our firm. The response in an individual case depends on the facts, so please check with your agent.

  • The time limit for correction is, in effect, closure of pleadings at the IP High Court of Korea. In general, we suggest that a patentee against whom a petition for a trial for invalidation has been filed prepare the proposed correction at the trial stage. The patentee files a request for correction in the trial for invalidation, and files a petition for a trial for correction before closure of pleadings in the revocation action. What the Majority Opinion said is reviewed in the fact-finding proceedings is the case where the trial decision for correction was made before closure of pleadings.
  • We suggest that a patentee headquartered outside Korea build into the schedule the time that approval of the proposed correction takes. If the review of a correction starts only after new evidence is produced at the IP High Court of Korea, it is difficult to meet closure of pleadings.
  • If a petition for a trial for correction has been filed while the case is before the IP High Court of Korea, we suggest informing the court of that fact and of the content of the correction. The Opinion concurring with the Majority Opinion named circumstances that the court looks at when deciding whether to close the pleadings. However, that opinion is not a standard held by the Majority Opinion.
  • If a defense pleading an abuse of right on the ground of invalidity is raised in patent infringement litigation, we suggest submitting the re-plea of correction in the fact-finding proceedings. The Majority Opinion stated that contesting on the ground that a trial decision for correction became final and conclusive after closure of pleadings, although no re-plea of correction was submitted, is not allowed.
  • The party that filed the petition for the trial for invalidation can respond on the premise that a trial decision for correction during the final appeal does not by itself lead to reversal of the lower judgment. However, the corrected claims can be disputed again in the trial proceedings that follow.
  • A trial decision for correction obtained after closure of pleadings is not useless. As in the case of the November 2020 decision, if the trial decision is revoked and the IPTAB examines the case again, the claims after correction become the subject of the examination.

FAQ

If a trial decision for correction becomes final and conclusive after closure of pleadings at the IP High Court of Korea, does the Supreme Court reverse the lower judgment?

Not merely because the trial decision for correction became final and conclusive. The Supreme Court held that the lower judgment decided on the specification before correction has no grounds for retrial under the Civil Procedure Act, Art. 451(1), subparagraph 8. [1]

Which claims does the court of final appeal determine, those before correction or those after correction?

The claims before correction. The November 2020 decision held that the court of final appeal must determine inventive step on the specification before the trial decision for correction became final and conclusive. [3]

Does this legal principle also apply to patent infringement litigation?

Yes. The en banc decision stated that this legal principle applies as it is to civil litigation arising from patent infringement. [1] The January 2021 decision applied this standard in patent infringement litigation. [4]

Until when can a patentee respond by correction?

The Majority Opinion named two stages. The patentee can respond by a request for correction in the trial for invalidation of a patent, and by a petition for a trial for correction in the fact-finding proceedings of the revocation action. [1] The Patent Act, Art. 136(2) sets the periods during which a petition for a trial for correction cannot be filed. [8]

Did the patentee lose in this case?

No. The ground of appeal on the trial decision for correction was not accepted. However, the Supreme Court found that the inventive step of the claims before correction is not denied, reversed the lower judgment and remanded the case to the IP High Court of Korea. [1]

How DEFINE IP Law Firm handles this

At the stage of responding to a trial for invalidation, DEFINE IP Law Firm checks the need for a correction and its timing together. We look at in which proceedings and by when a correction must be asserted in light of the standard of this decision. We do not present content that is not in the written judgment as the standard of the decision. For questions about corrections and invalidity disputes over Korean patents, please write to contact@defineip.kr.

Sources

  1. Supreme Court en banc Decision 2016Hu2522 Decided January 22, 2020 (대법원 2020. 1. 22. 선고 2016후2522 전원합의체 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2016후2522) (verified 2026-10-09)
  2. Supreme Court Decision 2016Hu2546 Decided April 29, 2020 (대법원 2020. 4. 29. 선고 2016후2546 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2016후2546) (verified 2026-10-09)
  3. Supreme Court Decision 2017Hu2055 Decided November 26, 2020 (대법원 2020. 11. 26. 선고 2017후2055 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2017후2055) (verified 2026-10-09)
  4. Supreme Court Decision 2017Da231829 Decided January 14, 2021 (대법원 2021. 1. 14. 선고 2017다231829 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2017다231829) (verified 2026-10-09)
  5. Supreme Court Decision 2019Hu10296 Decided December 30, 2021 (대법원 2021. 12. 30. 선고 2019후10296 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2019후10296) (verified 2026-10-09)
  6. Supreme Court Decision 2019Hu10456 Decided June 16, 2022 (대법원 2022. 6. 16. 선고 2019후10456 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2019후10456) (verified 2026-10-09)
  7. Supreme Court Decision 99Hu598 Decided October 12, 2001 (대법원 2001. 10. 12. 선고 99후598 판결), Supreme Court Decision 2007Hu852 Decided July 24, 2008 (대법원 2008. 7. 24. 선고 2007후852 판결), Supreme Court Decision 2000Da69194 Decided October 28, 2004 (대법원 2004. 10. 28. 선고 2000다69194 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(99후598) , https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2007후852) , https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2000다69194) (verified 2026-10-09)
  8. Patent Act (특허법), Act No. 21134, in force from 2025-11-11. Art. 132-3, Art. 133-2, Art. 136, Art. 137, Art. 186, Art. 189, and Addenda of Act No. 14035 (promulgated on 2016-02-29, in force from 2017-03-01), Art. 1 and Art. 12. https://www.law.go.kr/법령/특허법 (verified 2026-10-09)
  9. Patent Act (특허법), Act No. 14112, in force from 2016-06-30 (the version in force on the date the petition for the trial for correction was filed). Art. 136. Version history at https://www.law.go.kr/법령/특허법 (verified 2026-10-09)
  10. Patent Act (특허법), Act No. 21955, promulgated on 2026-09-15, in force from 2027-03-16. Art. 132-3, Art. 133-2, Art. 136, Art. 137, Art. 186, Art. 189. https://www.law.go.kr/법령/특허법 (verified 2026-10-09)
  11. Civil Procedure Act (민사소송법), Act No. 21993, in force from 2026-10-02. Art. 451(1), subparagraph 8. https://www.law.go.kr/법령/민사소송법 (verified 2026-10-09)
  12. Administrative Litigation Act (행정소송법), Act No. 21615, in force from 2026-05-12. Art. 8(2). https://www.law.go.kr/법령/행정소송법 (verified 2026-10-09)