Brief summary
- In Korean examination, a computer program per se is not an invention. A “computer program stored on a medium” (매체에 저장된 컴퓨터프로그램) is a claim format that can be used.
- The “computer program stored on a medium” format applies to applications filed on or after 1 July 2014.
- Claims that end with “program product”, “program signal” or a “transmission medium” that transmits a program are regarded as not clear.
- The Korean Patent Act has no wording that includes a program in a product. For method claims, “offering the use of the method” was added as an act of working on 11 March 2020.
The statute is the Patent Act (특허법) in force from 11 November 2025. The examination standard is the Patent Examination Guidelines (특허·실용신안 심사기준) in force from 13 March 2026. The treatment of each claim format follows the Examination Practice Guidelines by Technology Field (기술분야별 심사실무가이드, March 2026) of the Ministry of Intellectual Property (지식재산처). Last verified on 9 October 2026.
Last verified
Claim formats at a glance
As of October 2026. The basis column gives the section numbers of Chapter 10, “Computer-related Invention” (컴퓨터 관련 발명), in the “Other” (기타) part of the Examination Practice Guidelines by Technology Field (“the Practice Guidelines”). [3]
| Claim ending | Treatment in Korean examination | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| A method comprising steps A, B and C | Can be written as a method invention | 1.2.1 (1) |
| An apparatus specified by its functions | Can be written as a product invention | 1.2.1 (2) |
| A computer-readable medium on which a program is recorded | Can be written as a product invention | 1.2.1 (2) ① |
| A computer-readable medium on which structured data is recorded | Can be written as a product invention | 1.2.1 (2) ② |
| A computer program stored on a medium | Can be written. Applies to applications filed from 1 July 2014 | 1.2.1 (2) ③ |
| A computer program not stored on a medium | Not allowed. It is regarded as claiming a computer program per se | 1.2.1 (2) ③ |
| Program product (프로그램 제품, 프로그램 프로덕트), program outcome (프로그램 산출물) | The subject of the invention is regarded as not clear | 1.2.2 (2) |
| Program signal, program signal sequence | The category of the invention is regarded as not clear | 1.2.2 (4) |
| An information transmission medium that is transmitting a specific computer program | The invention is regarded as not clear | 1.2.2 (3) |
The Practice Guidelines are not a statute. They are an examination standard that examiners follow. The Patent Examination Guidelines, Part 3, Chapter 1, 4.1.8, refer to this chapter for computer programs. [2]
A program per se is not an invention, but a program stored on a medium is
The Korean Examination Guidelines do not regard a computer program per se as an invention. Part 3, Chapter 1, 4.1.8 of the Patent Examination Guidelines describes a computer program as “a mere list of instructions to operate a computer”. [2]
The same section also states an exception. The exception is the case where information processing by the program is concretely realized by using hardware. In that case, four things are inventions. [2]
- the information processing apparatus that operates together with the program
- the method of its operation
- a computer-readable medium on which the program is recorded
- a computer program stored on a medium
The statutory basis is the Patent Act, Art. 2, subparagraph 1, and the main clause of Art. 29(1). Art. 2, subparagraph 1 defines an invention as “the highly advanced creation of a technical idea using the laws of nature”. [1] Part 3, Chapter 1, 3. of the Examination Guidelines reads the requirements of the main clause of Art. 29(1) as including subject matter eligibility (발명의 성립요건). [2] An application that cannot be granted a patent under Art. 29 falls under the ground for rejection in Art. 62, subparagraph 1. [1]
A programming language and a program listing are not inventions either. Chapter 10, 2.1.3 (4) of the Practice Guidelines regards a programming language as an artificial decision. The same section, at (5), regards a program listing per se as a mere presentation of information. [3]
“A computer program stored on a medium” applies to applications filed on or after 1 July 2014
To end a claim with a program, the limitation “stored on a medium” must be included. The example in the Practice Guidelines is “a computer program stored on a medium to cause a computer to execute step A, step B, step C, …”. [3]
The Practice Guidelines attach conditions to the name of this format. The name is “a claim to a computer program that is combined with hardware and stored on a medium to solve a specific problem”. [3]
A term equivalent to “computer program” can be used instead. The Practice Guidelines give a claim ending with “an application stored on a computer-readable storage medium” as an allowed example. [3]
Without “stored on a medium”, the claim is not allowed. The example that the Practice Guidelines give as not allowed is “a computer program that causes a computer to execute step A, step B, step C, …”. The reason is that the claim is directed to a computer program per se. [3]
This format carries the note “applies to applications filed from 1 July 2014”. [2][3] An application filed before that date is not covered by this format. Claims to a medium on which a program is recorded carry no such date note. [3]
The Examination Guidelines and the Practice Guidelines do not state separately which date “filed” in this note refers to. [2][3] For a PCT national phase application, there is the Patent Act, Art. 199(1). This provision states that an international application designating Korea is “deemed a patent application filed on the international filing date”. [1]
Some wording is regarded as not clear in Korean examination
Some program claim wording that is accepted in other countries is regarded as not clear under the Korean examination standard. The statutory basis is the Patent Act, Art. 42(4), subparagraph 2. A claim must satisfy the requirement that “the invention shall be clearly and concisely described”. [1] An application that does not meet this requirement falls under the ground for rejection in Art. 62, subparagraph 4. [1]
Chapter 10, 1.2.2 and 1.2.3 of the Practice Guidelines list the following cases. [3]
| Wording or situation | Assessment in the Practice Guidelines | Section |
|---|---|---|
| The claim ends with “program product” (프로그램 제품, 프로그램 프로덕트) or “program outcome” (프로그램 산출물) | The invention is not clear, because it is difficult to determine whether the subject is a recording medium or a computer system | 1.2.2 (2) |
| The claim ends with “program signal” or “program signal sequence” | The category cannot be determined as a product or a method | 1.2.2 (4) |
| “An information transmission medium that is transmitting a specific computer program” | Not clear, because there is no technical relationship between the functions of the program and the transmission medium | 1.2.2 (3) |
| “A medium on which a program having … means is recorded” | Not clear, because a program per se cannot have means | 1.2.2 (1), Example 2 |
| “Using a computer, a step of …” | The entity that performs each step is not clearly specified | 1.2.2 (1), Example 1 |
| The entity that performs the invention (the hardware) cannot be clearly identified from the claim | The claim is regarded as not clearly stated | 1.2.3 (1) |
| Part of a program listing, such as source code, is written in the claim | Regarded as not clear. There is an exception if the listing is simple and a person skilled in the art can understand it | 1.2.3 (3) |
The “program having means” problem is solved by changing the subject of the sentence. The wording that the Practice Guidelines regard as clear is “a computer-readable medium on which a program for causing a computer to function as … means is recorded”. [3]
The expression “using a computer” also has an exception (1.2.2 (1) (iv)). The exception is the case where a person skilled in the art can clearly specify the invention in view of the description of the invention, the drawings and the common general technical knowledge at the time of filing. In that case, the claim is regarded as clearly stated. [3]
“Transmission medium” in the description of the invention makes a recording medium claim unclear
Even if the claim ends with “a computer-readable recording medium”, an objection can arise from the description of the invention. Chapter 10, 1.2.3 (2) of the Practice Guidelines gives the example of a description of the invention that includes transmission media in the recording medium. [3]
In the example in the Practice Guidelines, the description of the invention stated that the recording medium includes hard disks and optical recording media. It also stated that the recording medium includes transmission media such as carrier waves. The Practice Guidelines regard this claim as not clear, because it states both recording media and transmission media as the subject of protection. [3]
The Practice Guidelines also state the solution. They state that it is desirable for the examiner to propose an amendment that deletes the statements relating to transmission media from the description of the invention. [3]
Conversely, the description of the invention does not have to define the recording medium. If a person skilled in the art can specify the subject as a recording medium in view of the common general technical knowledge at the time of filing, the claim can be regarded as clearly stated. [3]
Cooperation with hardware must be stated in the claim
Subject matter eligibility is assessed on the claim, not on the description of the invention. This is the content of Chapter 10, 2.1.3 (1) of the Practice Guidelines. If the claim does not show that information processing by software is concretely realized by using hardware, the claimed subject matter is not an invention. [3]
Naming the hardware may not be enough. Section 2.1.3 (2) deals with the case where “computer”, “processor” or “memory” is stated in the claim. If the claim does not state concrete means or a concrete method in which software and hardware cooperate, the claimed subject matter may not be an invention. [3]
The same section also gives a standard in the opposite direction. This is the case where the claim concretely states the calculation or processing of information that is specific to the purpose of use. In that case, the calculation or processing can be regarded as realized even if the only hardware stated is an ordinary “computer”. [3]
The assessment does not depend on the category of the invention stated in the claim (2.1.3 (3)). The Practice Guidelines state that the assessment is made after interpreting the meaning of the matters that specify the invention. [3]
Functional limitations in a claim are allowed subject to a condition. The basis is the Patent Examination Guidelines, Part 2, Chapter 4, 4.(7). A functional limitation is allowed only where the configuration of the invention as a whole is clear even with that limitation. [2] The same section gives computer-related inventions as an example of a field in which it is difficult to express an invention only by stating a concrete structure. [2] If the matter for which a patent is sought cannot be clearly identified, a ground for rejection for violation of Art. 42(4), subparagraph 2 is notified. [2] The Practice Guidelines also state that a computer-related invention can be written as a product invention specified by its functions. [3]
The acts covered by the right differ by claim format
The Patent Act, Art. 2, subparagraph 3 defines the acts of working differently for each type of invention. [1] A medium claim and a claim to a program stored on a medium are formats that the Practice Guidelines place under product inventions. [3]
| Invention | Acts of working | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Product invention | Manufacturing, using, assigning, leasing, exporting or importing the product, or offering to assign or lease it | Art. 2, subparagraph 3 (a) |
| Method invention | Using the method, or offering the use of the method | Art. 2, subparagraph 3 (b) |
| Invention of a process for manufacturing a product | The acts in item (b), and using, assigning, leasing, exporting or importing the product manufactured by the process, or offering to assign or lease it | Art. 2, subparagraph 3 (c) |
The Korean Patent Act has no wording that includes a program in a product. The word “program” (프로그램) does not appear at all in the Patent Act in force from 11 November 2025. [1] The same is true of the amended Patent Act (Act No. 21955) that is scheduled to enter into force on 16 March 2027. [1]
For method inventions, one act of working was added on 11 March 2020. It is “the act of offering the use of the method”, inserted by Act No. 16804. [1] The working of an invention of a process for manufacturing a product also includes the acts in item (b) (Art. 2, subparagraph 3 (c)). [1] The statement of reasons for the amendment provided by the Ministry of Government Legislation (법제처) refers to the transmission of software. It states that it was unclear whether transmission through an information and communications network was an act of working. [1]
This act of working is subject to a limit. The limit is set in the Patent Act, Art. 94(2). The patent right extends only to the act of offering the use of the method “with the knowledge” that the use of the method infringes the patent right or an exclusive license. [1]
The Addenda to Act No. 16804 set only the date of entry into force. They contain no applicability provision and no transitional measure for acts before that date or for patents filed before that date. [1]
“Exporting” became an act of working a product invention on 22 July 2025 (Act No. 20700). [1] Art. 2, subparagraph 3 (a) of the Patent Act in force from 21 August 2024 did not contain “exporting”. [1]
How Korea differs
Korea differs from Japan and Europe in that it requires the limitation “stored on a medium” in a program claim.
| Country | Program claims | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Korea | “A computer program stored on a medium” can be written. A program not stored on a medium is not allowed, and program products and program signals are regarded as not clear | Examination Practice Guidelines by Technology Field, Chapter 10, 1.2.1 and 1.2.2 [3] |
| Japan | The Patent Act provides that a product includes a program, etc. “Assignment, etc.” of a program, etc. includes providing it through telecommunication lines | 特許法, Art. 2(3), item 1, and Art. 2(4) [4] |
| Europe (EPO) | “A computer program [product] comprising instructions …” and “A data carrier signal carrying the computer program [product] …” are examples of allowed wording | Guidelines F-IV, 3.9.1 [5] |
| United States | A computer program per se that is claimed as a product without any structural recitations does not fall within a statutory category. The MPEP states that a claim to a computer-readable medium that can be a compact disc or a carrier wave should be rejected under 35 U.S.C. 101 | MPEP 2106.03 [6] |
When a European-style claim set is brought to Korea, two claim endings must be checked. When “computer program product”, the EPO example, is translated into Korean, the claim ends with “프로그램 제품” (program product). The Korean Practice Guidelines regard a claim that ends with “프로그램 제품” or “프로그램 프로덕트” as not clear. [3][5]
The “data carrier signal” claim in the EPO example ends with a signal. The Korean Practice Guidelines regard a claim that ends with “program signal”, “program signal sequence” or the like as not clear in its category. [3][5]
Sentences that come from the specification of a US application also need to be checked. A description of the invention stating that the computer-readable medium includes carrier waves is the same case as the example in the Korean Practice Guidelines. The Practice Guidelines regard that recording medium claim as not clearly stated. [3] The MPEP states that a medium claim that can be a carrier wave should be rejected under 35 U.S.C. 101. The Korean Practice Guidelines treat it as a question of clarity. [3][6]
A claim from a Japanese application that ends with “program” also needs to be checked. The Japanese Patent Act includes a program, etc. in a product. The Korean Practice Guidelines do not allow a computer program that is not stored on a medium. [3][4]
What applicants should do
- In general, we suggest including four formats together: a method, an apparatus, a medium on which the program is recorded, and a computer program stored on a medium. The reason is that the acts covered by the right differ between a product invention and a method invention.
- We suggest checking the claim endings before entering the Korean national phase. The claims to check are those that end with “program product”, “signal” or “transmission medium”. An amendment to a claim ending that fits the Korean examination standard is worth considering.
- We suggest checking how the description of the invention defines the recording medium. Deleting by amendment a sentence stating that the recording medium includes carrier waves or transmission media is worth considering. The amendment proposed in the Practice Guidelines is also deletion. [3]
- Amendments are limited in scope. An amendment of an international patent application filed in a foreign language must stay within two scopes. One is the scope of the description of the invention, the claims or the drawings submitted by the international filing date. The other is the scope of the final Korean translation or the drawings submitted by the international filing date, excluding captions in the drawings (Patent Act, Art. 47(2), and Art. 208(3) and (4)). [1] Whether a deletion is within those scopes must be checked in the individual case.
- We suggest stating, in program claims and medium claims as well, how each step or function cooperates with the hardware. The reason is that subject matter eligibility is assessed on the claim.
- Please confirm the claim wording of an individual case with a Korean agent.
FAQ
Can a “computer program” be claimed in Korea?
Yes, if it is written as “a computer program stored on a medium”. This applies to applications filed on or after 1 July 2014. A computer program not stored on a medium is not allowed, because it is regarded as claiming a program per se. [3]
What happens to a “computer program product” claim in Korea?
A claim that ends with “프로그램 제품” or “프로그램 프로덕트” (program product) is regarded as not clear in the subject of the invention. The reason given is that it is difficult to determine whether the subject is a recording medium or a computer system. [3]
Does the claim need the word “non-transitory”?
The example wording in Chapter 10 of the Examination Practice Guidelines by Technology Field does not contain that word. The example in the Practice Guidelines is “a computer-readable medium on which a program is recorded”. [3] However, if the description of the invention includes transmission media in the recording medium, the claim is regarded as not clear. [3]
Is a claim that ends with “application” or “app” acceptable?
The Practice Guidelines give “an application stored on a computer-readable storage medium” as an allowed example. They treat “application” as a term equivalent to a computer program. [3] The word “app” (앱) does not appear in Chapter 10 of the Practice Guidelines.
Can a data structure be claimed?
It can be written as “a computer-readable medium on which structured data is recorded”. The Practice Guidelines regard a medium in which the recorded data structure specifies the processing performed by the computer as a product invention. [3]
How DEFINE IP Law Firm handles this
For Korean applications and national phase entries of software inventions, DEFINE IP Law Firm checks the claim endings first. We check the definition of the recording medium in the description of the invention at the same stage. We inform the applicant before entry of any wording that does not fit the Korean examination standard. For questions about program claims in Korean applications, please write to contact@defineip.kr.
Sources
- Patent Act (특허법), Act No. 21134, in force from 11 November 2025. Articles 2, 29(1), 42(4), 47(2), 62, 94, 199(1) and 208; Addenda (Act No. 16804, promulgated 10 December 2019, in force from 11 March 2020) and the statement of reasons for that amendment; Addenda (Act No. 20700, promulgated 21 January 2025, in force from 22 July 2025). Compared with the version scheduled to enter into force (Act No. 21955, in force from 16 March 2027). https://www.law.go.kr/법령/특허법 (verified 9 October 2026)
- Ministry of Intellectual Property (지식재산처), Patent Examination Guidelines (특허·실용신안 심사기준), MOIP Established Rule No. 7, in force from 13 March 2026. Part 2, Chapter 4, 4.(7); Part 3, Chapter 1, 3., 4. and 4.1.8. https://www.law.go.kr/행정규칙/특허·실용신안심사기준 (verified 9 October 2026)
- Ministry of Intellectual Property (지식재산처), Examination Practice Guidelines by Technology Field (기술분야별 심사실무가이드), March 2026, Other (formerly the Examination Guidelines by Technology Field), Chapter 10, Computer-related Invention (컴퓨터 관련 발명), 1.2.1 to 1.2.3 and 2.1.3. https://www.kipo.go.kr/ko/kpoContentView.do?menuCd=SCD0200147 (verified 9 October 2026)
- Japan, Patent Act (特許法, 昭和三十四年法律第百二十一号), Article 2, current version shown on e-Gov 法令検索 (latest amendment in force from 24 June 2026). https://laws.e-gov.go.jp/law/334AC0000000121 (verified 9 October 2026)
- EPO, Guidelines for Examination, Part F, Chapter IV, 3.9.1, 2026 edition (publication date shown: 31 March 2026). https://www.epo.org/en/legal/guidelines-epc/2026/f_iv_3_9_1.html (verified 9 October 2026)
- USPTO, MPEP 2106.03 Eligibility Step 1: The Four Categories of Statutory Subject Matter [R-07.2022], page last modified 9 March 2026. https://www.uspto.gov/web/offices/pac/mpep/s2106.html (verified 9 October 2026)