← 글 목록← All articles

How much support must the description give the claims in Korea?

Brief summary

  • A Korean claim must be supported by the description of the invention (Patent Act, Art. 42(4), subparagraph 1). A breach is a ground for rejection and, after registration, a ground for invalidation.
  • The test uses the state of the art at the time of filing and the position of a person skilled in the art. The question is whether the description of the invention states matter that corresponds to the matter stated in the claim.
  • A claim can be broader than the embodiments. It must be possible to extend or generalize the content disclosed in the description of the invention to the scope of the claim.
  • The Examination Guidelines treat an amendment that adds embodiments or test examples after filing as, in general, an addition of new matter.

The provisions are those of the Patent Act (특허법), Act No. 21134, in force from 11 November 2025. The Patent Examination Guidelines (특허·실용신안 심사기준) are the version in force from 13 March 2026. Last verified on 9 October 2026.

Last verified

Effects of the support requirement at a glance

As of October 2026. The request for revocation of a granted patent (특허취소신청) applies only to patent rights for which the registration of the grant of a patent (registration of establishment of a patent right) was made on or after 1 March 2017 (Addenda to Act No. 14035, Art. 10).

Stage If the support requirement (뒷받침 요건) is not met Basis
Examination It is a ground for rejection. The examiner issues a notice of grounds for rejection and gives an opportunity to submit a written argument Patent Act, Art. 62, subparagraph 4, and Art. 63(1)
Amendment An amendment is possible only within the matters described in the original specification or drawings Art. 47(2), former part
Request for revocation of a granted patent It is not a ground for the request. The grounds are some breaches of Art. 29 and breaches of Art. 36(1) to (3) Art. 132-2(1)
Trial for invalidation It is a ground for invalidation. If there are two or more claims, the trial can be requested claim by claim Art. 133(1), subparagraph 1
Correction The patentee can request a correction that narrows the claims Art. 136(1), subparagraph 1, and Art. 133-2(1)

The test is whether corresponding matter is stated in the description of the invention

The support requirement prevents a patent right from being granted for an invention that was not disclosed. Supreme Court Decision 2004Hu1120 Decided May 11, 2006 stated this purpose. [3]

The same decision gives the test. From the position of a person skilled in the art, the question is whether matter corresponding to the invention stated in the claims is stated in the description of the invention. [3] Supreme Court Decision 2012Hu832 Decided September 4, 2014 held that the reference point is the state of the art at the time of filing. [4]

The Examination Guidelines state that the examination looks at scope, not at whether the wording is identical. The main point of review is the scope of the claimed invention. The examiner reviews whether that scope goes beyond what a person skilled in the art can understand from the description of the invention (Examination Guidelines, Part 2, Chapter 4, 3. (1)). [2]

In the Examination Guidelines, the description of the invention means the content of the specification other than the claims. [2] Article 42(2) of the Patent Act defines the specification as a document that states the description of the invention and the claims. [1] Matter stated only in the claims is therefore not a statement in the description of the invention within the meaning of Art. 42(4), subparagraph 1.

The drawings are taken into account in assessing support. Supreme Court Decision 2004Hu776 Decided October 13, 2006 held so. Where drawings are attached, support can be assessed by considering the drawings and the brief description of the drawings together. [6] The same decision also held that drawings alone cannot replace the detailed description of the invention. [6] In that case, the Supreme Court upheld the lower court, which had found that the invention of claim 6 was not supported even when the drawings were taken into account. [6] The Examination Guidelines state that the same method applies to matter stated only in the drawings (Part 2, Chapter 4, 3. (3)). [2]

A claim broader than the embodiments is accepted as far as the disclosure can be extended or generalized

A claim does not need to have the same scope as the embodiments. The test in Supreme Court Decision 2014Hu2061 Decided May 26, 2016 is extension or generalization. The reference point is the state of the art at the time of filing. A claim is supported if the content disclosed in the description of the invention can be extended or generalized to the scope of the invention stated in the claims. [5]

The patent in that case was a biosensor with a protrusion in the sample introduction part. The description of the invention stated the position and role of the protrusion, and the methods of making and using the sample introduction part. Figure 1 showed a form in which the protrusion was formed. There was no specific statement on the size or shape of the protrusion. The Supreme Court held that the claim could not be regarded as unsupported, and reversed the judgment of the lower court. [5]

Decision 2004Hu1120 is an example of the opposite result. The claim did not specify the composition by chemical name or chemical formula. It used the expression “collagenase-3 selective inhibitor”. The description of the invention listed 16 compounds, and experimental results on the pharmacological effect were given for only 2 of them. The Supreme Court upheld the lower court, which had found that the claim was not supported. [3]

The wording of Decision 2004Hu1120 is as follows. A claim cannot be regarded as supported if the disclosed content cannot be extended or generalized to the claimed scope even in light of the common general technical knowledge at the time of filing. [3]

Supreme Court Decision 2021Hu10886 Decided October 8, 2024 is an example on numerical ranges. The claim limited the total track length (TTL) of a lens assembly to a certain length or less. The TTL values of the embodiments disclosed in the description of the invention were 5.904 mm and 5.90 mm. The Supreme Court stated that there was no material showing that those embodiments could be extended or generalized to the numerical range of TTL in the claim. It upheld the lower court, which had found that the claim was not supported, and dismissed the appeal. [10]

The Examination Guidelines list five types of unsupported claims

The types are listed in Part 2, Chapter 4, 3. (2) of the Examination Guidelines. [2]

No. Type of unsupported claim
① Matter corresponding to the matter stated in the claim is neither directly stated nor suggested in the description of the invention
② Terms are not used consistently between the description of the invention and the claim, so the correspondence is unclear
③ The claim is written as a means or a step for performing a specific function, but the description of the invention has no corresponding specific structure
④ In light of the common general technical knowledge at the time of filing, the content stated in the description of the invention cannot be extended or generalized to the scope of the claimed invention
⑤ The claim omits a feature that the description of the invention explains as essential for solving the problem, so the claim is found to cover an invention beyond what a person skilled in the art can recognize from the description of the invention

One example of type ① concerns numerical values. The claim contains a specific numerical limitation, but the description of the invention has no statement on that value. There is a proviso. Support can be accepted if the value is within what a person skilled in the art can understand from the description of the invention in light of the common general technical knowledge at the time of filing. [2]

Another example of type ① concerns a motor. The claim states an ultrasonic motor, and the description of the invention states only a DC motor. There is a proviso here as well. The description of the invention must state that other motors can also be used. Carrying out the invention with an ultrasonic motor must also be possible under the common general technical knowledge at the time of filing. If both conditions are met, support can be accepted. [2]

There are four examples of type ④. [2]

  • A claim that specifies the invention by the result to be achieved (for example, a range of energy efficiency)
  • A claim to a therapeutic agent for a specific use whose active ingredient is a compound defined by a desired property
  • The case of Decision 2004Hu1120
  • A claim that limits the numerical range of a parameter

The Examination Guidelines attach conditions to each example. For the parameter claim there are two conditions. The description of the invention must have no specific embodiments covering the whole numerical range. Outside the range in which the embodiments confirm a better effect, that effect must not be recognized even under the common general technical knowledge at the time of filing. [2]

There are two examples of type ⑤, and one of them concerns a rice cake filling. The description of the invention explained that only a cream with a lower moisture content than the rice cake can be used as the filling. The claim stated only “cream”, without regard to moisture content. [2]

The support requirement is assessed separately from the enablement requirement

The support requirement (Art. 42(4), subparagraph 1) and the enablement requirement (Art. 42(3), subparagraph 1) are separate requirements. Decision 2012Hu832 held that the support requirement must not be assessed by the test for the enablement requirement. [4]

In that case, matter corresponding to the features of claim 8 was stated in identical terms in the detailed description of the invention. The Supreme Court found that the lower court was right to find no breach of the support requirement, and dismissed the appeal of the Commissioner of the Korean Intellectual Property Office. [4]

The Examination Guidelines divide the application of the two provisions as follows (Part 2, Chapter 3, 2.4). [2]

Provision When it applies
Art. 42(3), subparagraph 1 An average technician cannot easily carry out the invention of the claim from the statements in the description of the invention
Art. 42(4), subparagraph 1 The invention stated in the claim is not stated in the description of the invention, or it goes beyond what an average technician can recognize from the content stated in the description of the invention

In some cases both provisions apply together. One example is a claim to a generic concept where the description of the invention contains only specific concepts. If the invention of the generic concept cannot be clearly understood from the statements on the specific concepts, Art. 42(4), subparagraph 1 applies. If there is a specific reason to find that other specific concepts cannot be carried out easily, Art. 42(3), subparagraph 1 applies as well. [2]

Article 42 as a whole, including the enablement requirement, is covered in “What does Article 42 of the Korean Patent Act require of the description and claims?“

After an objection, the applicant narrows the claims or argues in a written argument

A ground for rejection under the support requirement is answered by an amendment or a written argument. If the application has two or more claims, the examiner must clearly identify the rejected claims in the notice. The examiner must also state the grounds for rejection for those claims specifically (Patent Act, Art. 63(2)). [1]

An amendment must be made within the matters described in the original specification or drawings (Art. 47(2), former part). [1] The Examination Guidelines state that an amendment that adds embodiments or test examples is, in general, an addition of new matter. The exception is where the addition can be regarded as within the content of the original specification or drawings (Part 4, Chapter 2, 1.2 (9)). [2] An amendment beyond this scope is a ground for rejection and a ground for invalidation (Art. 62, subparagraph 5, and Art. 133(1), subparagraph 6). [1]

An experimental report filed with a written argument cannot become part of the specification. The Examination Guidelines treat such material as material that explains or proves that the matter stated in the description of the invention is correct. They state that it can be referred to in assessing the requirements for patentability (Part 5, Chapter 3, 6.2 (2)). [2]

After a notice of grounds for rejection, an amendment can be filed only at fixed times. These are the period for submission of a written argument for that notice and the time when re-examination (재심사) is requested (proviso to Art. 47(1)). [1] At two of these times, amendment of the claims is further limited. They are the period for submission of a written argument for a notice that addresses grounds caused by an amendment, and the time when re-examination is requested. At these times, the claims can be amended only in the cases listed in the subparagraphs of Art. 47(3). One of them is an amendment that narrows the claims by limiting a claim, deleting a claim or adding a feature to a claim. [1]

An amendment filed at these two times can be dismissed. The examiner dismisses, by decision, an amendment that breaches Art. 47(2) or (3). The examiner also dismisses an amendment that gives rise to a new ground for rejection (main clause of Art. 51(1)). [1] A ground for rejection that arises from an amendment deleting a claim is excluded. The amendments listed in the subparagraphs of the proviso to Art. 51(1) are also not subject to dismissal. [1]

Re-examination also has limits. It cannot be requested if a decision to grant or reject has already been made following re-examination. A request for re-examination cannot be withdrawn (Art. 67-2(1), subparagraph 1, and Art. 67-2(4)). [1]

The permitted scope of amendment is covered in “What counts as new matter in Korea?” and “What amendments are allowed after a notice of final rejection in Korea?” Re-examination is covered in “What is re-examination in Korea, and when should it be requested?“

After registration, it is a ground for invalidation but not a ground for a request for revocation of a granted patent

A breach of the support requirement is a ground for a trial for invalidation. Article 133(1), subparagraph 1 of the Patent Act lists a breach of Art. 42(4) as a ground for invalidation. [1] The trial can be requested by an interested party or an examiner. If there are two or more claims, the trial can be requested claim by claim. [1] For patent rights registered before 1 March 2017, the previous Art. 133(1) applies (Addenda to Act No. 14035, Art. 21). [1] When a trial decision of invalidation becomes final, the patent right is deemed never to have existed (main clause of Art. 133(3)). [1]

Article 42 is not among the grounds for a request for revocation of a granted patent. The grounds listed in Art. 132-2(1) are some breaches of Art. 29 and breaches of Art. 36(1) to (3). [1]

The patentee can respond by correction. Article 136(1), subparagraph 1 allows a trial for correction (정정심판) that narrows the claims. [1] A trial for correction cannot be requested while a trial for invalidation is pending before the Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board (IPTAB) (Art. 136(2), subparagraph 2). [1] During that time, the patentee files a request for correction (정정청구) within the period designated in the trial for invalidation (Art. 133-2(1)). [1] A trial for correction also cannot be requested from the time a request for revocation of a granted patent is pending before the IPTAB until the decision on it becomes final. However, if an action requesting revocation of a decision rendered by the IPTAB (legal proceedings against trial rulings) in a trial for invalidation is pending before the Intellectual Property High Court of Korea (Patent Court of Korea), a trial for correction can be requested until the date on which the pleadings are closed (Art. 136(2), subparagraph 1). [1]

Correction also has limits. A correction can be made within the matters described in the specification or drawings of the patented invention (main clause of Art. 136(3)). It must not substantially extend or amend the claims (Art. 136(4)). [1] Article 133-2(4) applies these two paragraphs mutatis mutandis to a request for correction in a trial for invalidation. [1]

A correction that narrows the claims has one more requirement. The matter stated in the claims after the correction must have been patentable at the time the patent application was filed (Art. 136(5)). [1] This paragraph does not apply mutatis mutandis where a claim against which the trial for invalidation was requested is corrected by a request for correction (Art. 133-2(6)). [1]

Four Supreme Court decisions were decided under the previous wording, “detailed description of the invention”

The wording of Art. 42(4), subparagraph 1 was changed by the amendment that entered into force on 1 January 2015 (Act No. 12753). [1] The wording of the version immediately before the amendment (in force from 1 July 2014) is “supported by the detailed description of the invention” (발명의 상세한 설명에 의하여 뒷받침될 것). [7] The current wording is “supported by the description of the invention” (발명의 설명에 의하여 뒷받침될 것). [1]

Decisions 2004Hu1120, 2012Hu832, 2014Hu2061 and 2004Hu776 were decided under the previous wording, “detailed description of the invention”. [3][4][5][6] Decision 2021Hu10886 cited Art. 42(4), subparagraph 1 of the Patent Act without marking it as a former version, and stated the same test with the words “description of the invention”. [10] The text of that decision does not give the filing date of the patent. So the decision alone does not show which version of Art. 42 applied in that case. [10] The current Examination Guidelines also cite Decisions 2004Hu1120, 2012Hu832 and 2004Hu776 when explaining the current provision. [2]

For an international patent application in a foreign language, check the terms in the Korean translation

The filing date of an international patent application (PCT application designating Korea) is the international filing date. Article 199(1) of the Patent Act provides that an international application designating Korea is deemed a patent application filed on its international filing date. [1] The Examination Guidelines also state that the examiner examines the application with the international filing date as the filing date (Part 5, Chapter 3, 4.6 (2)). [2]

An international patent application filed in a foreign language is deemed amended according to the Korean translation. The basis is Article 201(5) of the Patent Act. If the final Korean translation is filed by the reference date, the description of the invention and the claims submitted by the international filing date are deemed amended according to that translation. For the drawings, this applies only to the captions in the drawings. The date of the amendment is deemed to be the international filing date. [1]

The reference date is the expiration date of the period for submitting domestic documents or, if examination was requested within that period, the date of that request (Art. 201(5)). [1] The period for submitting domestic documents is 2 years and 7 months from the priority date (main clause of Art. 201(1)). If the period for filing the translation was extended under the proviso to Art. 201(1), the extended period is the period for submitting domestic documents (Art. 201(3)). [1]

The Examination Guidelines call the specification or drawings as amended according to the Korean translation the “specification, etc. under examination” (심사대상 명세서등) (Part 5, Chapter 5, 1.4.1). They state that the examination of an application in a foreign language is basically the same as the examination of an ordinary application (Part 5, Chapter 5, 1.4). [2] Type ② is the case where terms are not used consistently between the description of the invention and the claim. In an international patent application in a foreign language, the text that the examiner compares is the specification as amended according to the Korean translation. [2]

A mistranslation can be corrected. The applicant can correct a mistranslation in the final Korean translation during the period in which an amendment can be filed (Art. 201(6), former part). [1] However, Art. 201(5) does not apply to the corrected Korean translation (Art. 201(6), latter part). [1] The Examination Guidelines state that a correction of mistranslation does not amend the specification. They state that, where there is a mistranslation, the specification, etc. under examination must be amended separately from the correction of mistranslation (Part 5, Chapter 5, 3.3 (2)). [2] Correction of mistranslation is covered in “How do I correct a mistranslation in a Korean patent application?“

The scope of amendment of an international patent application in a foreign language is assessed against the description of the invention, the claims or the drawings submitted by the international filing date (Art. 208(3)). [1] The amendment must also stay within the scope of the final Korean translation (Art. 208(4), and Art. 47(2), latter part). [1]

How Korea differs

Article 84 of the European Patent Convention (EPC) also requires the claims to be “supported by the description”. [8] The difference is after grant. Article 84 is not among the grounds for opposition (a) to (c) listed in Article 100 EPC, nor among the grounds for revocation (a) to (e) listed in Article 138(1) EPC. [8] In Korea, a breach of the support requirement is a ground for invalidation. [1]

The US patent statute, 35 U.S.C. 112(a), does not contain the word “supported”. It requires the specification to contain a “written description” of the invention. It also requires the specification to be written so that a person skilled in the art can make and use the invention. The text posted by the USPTO is the version that applies to applications filed on or after 16 September 2012. [9] Under 35 U.S.C. 282(b)(3)(A), failure to comply with a requirement of section 112 is one of the defenses of invalidity. Failure to disclose the best mode is excluded. [9]

What applicants should do

In general, we suggest the following. For an individual case, please check with a Korean agent.

  • Use the generic terms of the claims in the description of the invention as well, in the same words.
  • To claim a scope beyond the embodiments, state in the original specification why the disclosure can be extended to that scope.
  • If a numerical range is claimed, state the basis for the values and for both ends of the range in the description of the invention.
  • Under a broad independent claim, place dependent claims in steps down to the level of the embodiments. They give a position to narrow to if an objection is raised.
  • Before filing the Korean translation, check that the terms of the claims and of the description of the invention match.
  • Embodiments are difficult to add after filing. Prepare them at the stage of the priority application or the international application.

FAQ

Is it enough if the wording of the claim appears as it is in the description of the invention?

In Decision 2012Hu832, support was accepted because the corresponding matter was stated in identical terms. [4] However, the Examination Guidelines state that the main point of review is not whether the wording is identical, but whether the claim goes beyond what a person skilled in the art can understand. [2]

Can a broad claim be written with only one embodiment?

Yes. A claim is supported if the disclosed content can be extended or generalized to the claimed scope in light of the state of the art at the time of filing. [5] If it cannot be extended or generalized, the claim falls under type ④ of the Examination Guidelines. [2]

Does filing experimental data after a notice of grounds for rejection overcome the objection?

An experimental report cannot become part of the specification. It can be referred to as material that explains or proves that the matter stated in the description of the invention is correct. [2] An amendment that adds embodiments or test examples to the specification is, in general, an addition of new matter. [2]

Is content that appears only in the drawings taken into account?

Yes. The Examination Guidelines state that matter stated only in the drawings can also be assessed by considering the drawings and the brief description of the drawings together. [2] Drawings alone cannot replace the description of the invention. [6]

Does the support requirement still matter after registration?

Yes. A breach of Art. 42(4) is a ground for invalidation, and a trial for invalidation can be requested claim by claim (Patent Act, Art. 133(1)). [1]

How DEFINE IP Law Firm handles this

DEFINE IP Law Firm checks the support requirement at the stage of preparing a Korean application or entry into the Korean national phase. We check two things: the correspondence of terms between the claims and the description of the invention, and the scope of the claims against the scope of the embodiments. For questions about the claims and specification of Korean applications, please write to contact@defineip.kr.

Sources

  1. Patent Act (특허법), Act No. 21134, in force from 11 November 2025. Articles 42, 47, 51, 62, 63, 67-2, 132-2, 133, 133-2, 136, 199, 201 and 208; Addenda (Act No. 12753, in force from 1 January 2015), Art. 1; Addenda (Act No. 14035, in force from 1 March 2017), Arts. 1, 10 and 21. Compared with the version scheduled to enter into force (Act No. 21955, in force from 16 March 2027). https://www.law.go.kr/법령/특허법 (verified 9 October 2026)
  2. Ministry of Intellectual Property (지식재산처), Patent Examination Guidelines (특허·실용신안 심사기준), MOIP Established Rule (지식재산처예규) No. 7, in force from 13 March 2026. Part 2, Chapter 3, 2.4; Part 2, Chapter 4, 3; Part 4, Chapter 2, 1.2 (9); Part 5, Chapter 3, 4.6 and 6.2; Part 5, Chapter 5, 1.4 and 3.3. https://www.law.go.kr/행정규칙/특허·실용신안심사기준 (verified 9 October 2026)
  3. Supreme Court Decision 2004Hu1120 Decided May 11, 2006 (대법원 2006. 5. 11. 선고 2004후1120 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2004후1120) (verified 9 October 2026)
  4. Supreme Court Decision 2012Hu832 Decided September 4, 2014 (대법원 2014. 9. 4. 선고 2012후832 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2012후832) (verified 9 October 2026)
  5. Supreme Court Decision 2014Hu2061 Decided May 26, 2016 (대법원 2016. 5. 26. 선고 2014후2061 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2014후2061) (verified 9 October 2026)
  6. Supreme Court Decision 2004Hu776 Decided October 13, 2006 (대법원 2006. 10. 13. 선고 2004후776 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2004후776) (verified 9 October 2026)
  7. Patent Act (특허법), previous version (Act No. 11848), in force from 1 July 2014. Article 42. https://www.law.go.kr/법령/특허법 (version history, verified 9 October 2026)
  8. European Patent Office, European Patent Convention, Articles 84, 100, 138. https://www.epo.org/en/legal/epc/2020/a84.html (verified 9 October 2026)
  9. USPTO, MPEP Appendix L – Patent Laws, 35 U.S.C. 112, 282. Page marked as updated 9 March 2026. https://www.uspto.gov/web/offices/pac/mpep/mpep-9015-appx-l.html (verified 9 October 2026)
  10. Supreme Court Decision 2021Hu10886 Decided October 8, 2024 (대법원 2024. 10. 8. 선고 2021후10886 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2021후10886) (verified 9 October 2026)