← 글 목록← All articles

Supreme Court en banc Decision 2017Hu2819 Decided February 21, 2019: can a licensee file a petition for a trial for invalidation of a patent in Korea?

Brief summary

  • In principle, yes. In its en banc decision of 21 February 2019, the Supreme Court of Korea recognized the licensee in this case as an interested party. The standard of the Supreme Court is as follows. It may be that a licensee does not face, or has no reason to fear, an assertion of the patent right by the patentee. Barring special circumstances, that reason alone does not extinguish the licensee’s interest. [1]
  • The Supreme Court interpreted the interested party who may file a petition for a trial for invalidation (무효심판) as follows. It is a person who suffers or is likely to suffer a legal disadvantage from the continued existence of the right in the patented invention, and who therefore has a direct and actual interest in its extinction. [1]
  • This decision overruled earlier Supreme Court decisions that held that a person is not an interested party merely because that person is a licensee. They are overruled to the extent that they are inconsistent with the opinion of this decision. [1]
  • The provision that the decision interpreted is the former part of Art. 133(1) of the Patent Act (특허법) before amendment by Act No. 11654 (promulgated on 22 March 2013). The current Patent Act, Art. 133(1) also names an interested party or an examiner as the petitioner. However, the current provision places a limitation on the ground in the main clause of subparagraph 2. On that ground, only a person with the right to obtain a patent may file the petition as an interested party. [1] [5]

Last verified

The case

Item Details
Court Supreme Court of Korea
Date of decision 21 February 2019
Case number 2017Hu2819
Case name Invalidation of Registration (Patent)
Lower court Patent Court Decision 2017Heo2727 Decided October 27, 2017
Result The final appeal is dismissed
En banc or not En banc decision. It was decided by the assent of all participating Justices
Reference Provisions (as stated in the decision) [1] Former Patent Act (구 특허법) (before amendment by Act No. 11654 of 22 March 2013), Art. 133(1) / [2] Administrative Litigation Act (행정소송법), Art. 8(2) and Art. 27, Civil Procedure Act (민사소송법), Art. 142 / [3] the same former Patent Act, Art. 29(3) (see the current Art. 29(3) and (4))

The content of this table is taken from the written judgment. [1]

The issue: can a person who holds a license file a petition for a trial for invalidation of that patent?

The dispute was whether a licensee is an “interested party” under the Patent Act. The former part of Art. 133(1) of the Patent Act before amendment by Act No. 11654 (promulgated on 22 March 2013) named “an interested party or an examiner” as the petitioner. [1] [6]

The facts are as follows. The Plaintiff is the patentee of the patent at issue. The Plaintiff was a licensor that had listed the patent right at issue in the licensing program of a standard essential patent pool. The Defendant was also a licensor that had listed its own patent rights in the same program. At the same time, the Defendant was a licensee with the right to work (practice) the patented inventions on the list of that patent pool. The Defendant manufactured and sold goods that used technology of the same kind as the patented invention at issue. [1]

On 18 March 2016, the Defendant filed a petition for a trial for invalidation of the patent at issue with the Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board (IPTAB) (특허심판원). On 23 March 2017, the IPTAB rendered a trial decision that granted the Defendant’s petition in full. The Plaintiff filed an action requesting revocation of that trial decision with the Intellectual Property High Court of Korea (Patent Court of Korea) (특허법원). [2]

Before the IP High Court of Korea, the Plaintiff argued that the Defendant had no interest. The reason given was that the Defendant is a licensee of the patent at issue. The Plaintiff made three arguments. [2]

  • The Defendant holds a valid license for the term of the patent, so there is no reason for it to fear an assertion of the right by the Plaintiff.
  • Even if the patent at issue is invalidated, the license fees that the Defendant pays do not decrease.
  • The reliance interest between the licensors and licensees that take part in a standard essential patent pool needs to be protected.

The IP High Court of Korea dismissed the Plaintiff’s claim, and the Plaintiff filed a final appeal. [1] [2]

What the court held 1: an interested party is a person who suffers a legal disadvantage from the continued existence of the right

The Supreme Court first stated the meaning of an interested party. An interested party is a person who suffers or is likely to suffer some legal disadvantage from the continued existence of the right in that patented invention. Such a person therefore has a “direct and actual interest” in the extinction of the patent. [1]

The Supreme Court expressly named one group within this scope. It is persons who manufacture and sell goods of the same kind as that patented invention. Persons who will manufacture and sell goods of the same kind are also included. [1]

What the court held 2: the interest is not extinguished merely because there is no reason to fear an assertion of the right

From the legal principle above, the Supreme Court drew the standard for licensees. It may be that a licensee does not face, or has no reason to fear, an assertion of the patent right by the patentee. The Supreme Court held that, barring special circumstances, the interest cannot be found to have been extinguished “merely for that reason”. [1]

The Supreme Court gave two reasons. [1]

The first is the restrictions attached to a license. It is common for various restrictions to be imposed on a licensee, such as the payment of license fees or the scope of working. A licensee can be released from those restrictions by obtaining a trial decision for invalidation. [1]

The second is the circumstances in which a license is taken. Even if a patent has a ground for invalidation, the patent right remains validly in existence until a trial decision for invalidation becomes final and conclusive. It takes considerable time and cost until a trial decision for invalidation becomes final and conclusive. For that reason, even a person who wants to work the invention without a license may take a license first and postpone the dispute over invalidity. The Supreme Court held that it cannot be concluded that a person expressed an intention not to dispute invalidity merely because that person was granted a license. [1]

The Supreme Court applied this standard to the case. If a trial decision for invalidation of the patent at issue becomes final and conclusive, the agreement between the Plaintiff and the patent pool administrator loses effect under the license agreement. The patent at issue is removed from the licensing program. The Defendant can then work the patented invention at issue without any restriction. The Supreme Court held that the Defendant, as a licensee, is an interested party. [1]

A licensee's petition for a trial for invalidation and its interest

What the court did not decide

The Supreme Court did not give an example of what “special circumstances” are. [1] The lower court, the IP High Court of Korea, gave two examples. One is where the licensee was permitted to work the invention without any restriction, so that it can be regarded as having acquired the patent right itself. The other is where the licensee shares the same legal interest as the patentee, for example because a partnership relationship is formed between the parties. [2] These two examples do not appear in the written judgment of the Supreme Court. [1]

The Supreme Court did not decide the case where there is an agreement not to dispute the validity of the patent (a no-challenge agreement). [1] The lower court stated that there was no material showing that the agreement in this case contained a no-challenge agreement. [2]

The Supreme Court did not distinguish between an exclusive licensee and a non-exclusive licensee. The written judgment says only “licensee”. [1] The lower court found that the Defendant is an interested party even if it is regarded as having been granted a non-exclusive license. [2] The Patent Act divides licenses into the exclusive license (Art. 100) and the non-exclusive license (Art. 102). [5]

The Supreme Court did not deal in this decision with the question of license fees after a trial decision for invalidation becomes final and conclusive. [1]

Before and after this decision: it overruled earlier decisions

The decisions overruled

The Supreme Court overruled two decisions and other decisions to the same effect. They are Supreme Court Decision 76Hu7 Decided March 22, 1977 and Supreme Court Decision 82Hu58 Decided December 27, 1983. They are overruled “to the extent that they are inconsistent with the opinion of this decision”. The Supreme Court described those decisions as decisions that held to the effect that a person is not an interested party merely because that person is a licensee. [1]

Decision 82Hu58 was a case on invalidation of a utility model registration. In that case, the Supreme Court held that a person registered as a licensee does not fall within the category of interested parties for a petition for a trial for invalidation. [3] Decision 76Hu7 is not in the case materials of the Ministry of Government Legislation (법제처), so its full text could not be read.

Later decisions

The case search of the Ministry of Government Legislation did not return any decision that changed the standard of this decision (searched on 9 October 2026).

Has the provision that the decision applied changed since then?

The provision that the decision interpreted is the former part of Art. 133(1) of the Patent Act before amendment by Act No. 11654. [1] 22 March 2013 is the date of promulgation of Act No. 11654. This Act entered into force on 1 July 2013, except for some provisions (Addenda, Art. 1). Act No. 11654 did not change the wording of Art. 133(1). The wording is the same as in the version before Act No. 11654 was promulgated (Act No. 11117, in force from 15 March 2012). [6]

Art. 133(1) of the version before the amendment had a proviso. The proviso provided that any person may file a petition for a trial for invalidation from the date of registration of the grant of a patent (registration of establishment of a patent right) until 3 months after the date of publication of registration. However, the ground in subparagraph 2 was excluded. [6]

Art. 133(1) was amended by Act No. 14035. This Act was promulgated on 29 February 2016 and entered into force on 1 March 2017. Three things changed. [6]

Item Before Act No. 14035
Petitioner An interested party or an examiner An interested party or an examiner. In the case of the main clause of subparagraph 2, limited to a person with the right to obtain a patent
Period in which any person may file the petition From the date of registration until 3 months after the date of publication of registration (subparagraph 2 excluded) Deleted
Subparagraph 2 No proviso Excludes the case where a transfer has been registered under Art. 99-2(2)

The same Act newly introduced the request for revocation of a granted patent (특허취소신청). Any person may file a request for revocation of a granted patent. The period runs from the date of registration of the patent until the day on which 6 months have passed after the date of publication of registration (Art. 132-2(1)). The grounds are limited to the subparagraphs of Art. 132-2(1), and the restriction in paragraph (2) of the same Article applies. [5] [6]

The Addenda set the scope of application. The provisions on the request for revocation of a granted patent apply from patents registered on or after 1 March 2017 (Act No. 14035, Addenda, Art. 10). The previous Art. 133(1) applies to patents registered before 1 March 2017 (the same Addenda, Art. 21). [6]

Art. 133(1) was changed once more by Act No. 18505. This Act was promulgated on 19 October 2021 and entered into force on 20 April 2022. The current subparagraph 7 contains a ground for invalidation concerning the separational application (splitting-off) (분리출원). Subparagraph 7 of the version in force from 1 March 2017 did not contain the separational application. The Addenda set the scope of application of the provision on the separational application (Art. 52-2). It applies from a separational application that separates part of a patent application for which a petition for an appeal against the examiner’s decision to reject a patent application (trial on rulings rejecting patent applications) was filed on or after 20 April 2022 (Act No. 18505, Addenda, Art. 4). [5] [6]

The term “interested party” has remained the same through these amendments. What changed is the limitation attached to the ground in the main clause of subparagraph 2. [5] [6] The Supreme Court did not directly interpret the current provision. [1]

There is a Patent Act that has been promulgated and is not yet in force (Act No. 21955, promulgated on 15 September 2026, in force from 16 March 2027). Art. 133 and Art. 132-2 of this version have the same wording as the current provisions. [7]

Trials for invalidation under other Acts

Three other Acts also name an interested party or an examiner as the petitioner of a trial for invalidation. They are the Utility Model Act (실용신안법), Art. 31(1), the Design Protection Act (디자인보호법), Art. 121(1), and the Trademark Act (상표법), Art. 117(1). The Utility Model Act and the Design Protection Act have a limitation of the same form as the Patent Act. This is so for the ground in the main clause of subparagraph 5 of Art. 31(1) of the Utility Model Act and the ground in the main clause of subparagraph 1 of Art. 121(1) of the Design Protection Act. On these grounds, only a person with the right to obtain the registration may file the petition as an interested party. Art. 117(1) of the Trademark Act has no such limitation. [8]

The Utility Model Act and the Design Protection Act have versions that have been promulgated and are not yet in force (Act No. 21953 and Act No. 21951, both in force from 16 March 2027). In both versions, the wording on the petitioner in the provisions above is the same as in the current provisions. [8]

The provision that this decision interpreted is Art. 133(1) of the Patent Act. Decision 82Hu58, which this decision overruled, is a utility model case. [1] [3] In this decision, the Supreme Court did not deal with the provisions of the Design Protection Act or the Trademark Act. [1]

What happens to license fees already paid when the invalidation becomes final and conclusive?

Another Supreme Court decision dealt with this question. It is Supreme Court Decision 2012Da42666, 42673 Decided November 13, 2014. When the invalidation of a patent becomes final and conclusive, the patent right is deemed never to have existed (Patent Act, Art. 133(3), main clause). The case of invalidation on the ground in Art. 133(1), subparagraph 4 is different. In that case, the patent is deemed not to have existed from the time when it came to fall under subparagraph 4 (the proviso to the same paragraph). [5] The ground in subparagraph 4 is where, after the patent was granted, the patentee becomes a person who cannot enjoy the patent right, or the patent violates a treaty. [5] The Supreme Court also excluded the case of subparagraph 4 from its statement. [4]

The Supreme Court held that, despite the retroactive effect of the invalidation of a patent, the license agreement cannot be regarded as having been impossible to perform from the time it was concluded. The license agreement becomes impossible to perform from the time the invalidation becomes final and conclusive. [4]

For that reason, the patentee has no obligation to return the part of the license fees already received that corresponds to the period during which the license agreement validly existed. This conclusion has conditions. It does not hold if the license agreement was impossible to perform from the outset, or if the license agreement itself has a separate ground for invalidity. The Supreme Court also set apart the case where the working of the patented invention is impossible. [4]

Supreme Court Decision 2018Da287362 Decided April 25, 2019 applied the same legal principle to license fees not yet received. In principle, the patentee can claim payment of the license fees for the period during which the license agreement validly existed. This conclusion has the same conditions. It does not hold if the license agreement was impossible to perform from the outset, or if the license agreement itself has a separate ground for invalidity. [10]

No-challenge clauses and the review guidelines of the Korea Fair Trade Commission

The Review Guidelines on Unfair Exercise of Intellectual Property Rights (지식재산권의 부당한 행사에 대한 심사지침) of the Korea Fair Trade Commission (공정거래위원회) give examples of unfair conditions imposed when a license is granted. One of them is “imposition of a no-challenge obligation” (Ⅲ.3.라.(6)). The conduct that the Guidelines describe is unfairly prohibiting a licensee from disputing the validity of the related patent. The Guidelines attach to it the words “in order to maintain an invalid patent, etc.”. The Guidelines state that the imposition of such a condition can be found to go beyond the legitimate scope of the patent right. [9]

The Guidelines attach a reference note to this item. There are three cases that may be excluded. [9]

  • Where the licensee is required to notify the patentee of the fact of an infringement of the patent right concerned
  • Where the licensee is required to conduct patent-related litigation on the patentee’s behalf
  • Where the licensee is required to cooperate in the patentee’s conduct of litigation

The application of the Guidelines is limited. In principle, the Guidelines present the standards of judgment for two kinds of conduct. They are abusive practices by a market-dominant business entity and illegal cartel conduct between multiple business entities. There are cases where a business entity exercises an intellectual property right on its own. In such a case, the Guidelines apply, in principle, only when that business entity holds market-dominant power (Ⅱ.2.나). Whether each provision of the Monopoly Regulation and Fair Trade Act (공정거래법) has been violated is determined by comprehensively considering the illegality requirements of that provision (Ⅱ.2.나). [9]

The Guidelines also apply where an agreement that a foreign business entity made in or outside Korea affects the domestic market (Ⅰ.2.나). [9] The Guidelines are Korea Fair Trade Commission Established Rule (공정거래위원회예규) No. 389 and have been in force since 30 December 2021. [9] The Guidelines are review standards for the enforcement of the Monopoly Regulation and Fair Trade Act. The Guidelines do not determine whether a petition for a trial for invalidation is lawful when there is a no-challenge clause. [9]

The procedure of a trial for invalidation as a whole is covered in “How does a trial for invalidation work in Korea?“. The request for revocation of a granted patent is covered in “What is a request for revocation of a granted patent in Korea, and what is its deadline?”.

Other rulings in this decision

Apart from the petitioner’s standing, this decision contains three rulings. [1]

  • Reopening of pleadings: whether to accept a request to reopen pleadings after the closure of pleadings is, in principle, at the discretion of the court. The Supreme Court held that it is difficult to find that there were exceptional circumstances for reopening the pleadings in this case. [1]
  • Divisional application and priority claim: the written patent application of the patent at issue did not contain a statement of the intention to claim priority or an indication of the earlier application. The lower court therefore found that the effect of the priority claim is not recognized. The basis is Art. 55 and Art. 52(2) of the Patent Act before amendment by Act No. 11654. The Supreme Court held that this finding is justified. [1]
  • Identity under the expanded earlier application: there are cases where the difference in technical configuration is no more than the addition, deletion or change of well-known and commonly used art. If that difference is a minute difference to the degree that no new effect arises, the two inventions are substantially identical. The Supreme Court applied this standard of its earlier decisions as it is. [1]

The provisions on which the second ruling relied have changed since then. The current Patent Act, Art. 52(4) was newly inserted by Act No. 18505. This Act was promulgated on 19 October 2021 and entered into force on 20 April 2022. It is a provision on the case where the patent application on which the division is based is an application claiming priority. In that case, the priority is deemed to have been claimed for the divisional application as well at the time the divisional application is filed. [5] This provision applies from divisional applications filed on or after 20 April 2022 (Act No. 18505, Addenda, Art. 1 and Art. 3(2)). [6]

The period for a divisional application is covered in “When can I file a divisional application in Korea?“.

What changes in practice

The following is the opinion of our firm. The petitioner’s standing in an individual case depends on the agreement and the facts, so please check with your agent.

  • A licensee can include a trial for invalidation among its options. In general, we think it is right not to regard a petition for a trial for invalidation as barred merely by the fact that a license agreement was concluded.
  • We suggest that a patentee expect a petition for a trial for invalidation by the licensee even after granting a license. The Supreme Court held that it cannot be concluded that a person expressed an intention not to dispute invalidity merely because that person was granted a license.
  • The same applies to participants in a standard essential patent pool. The petitioner in this case was both a licensor and a licensee of the same patent pool.
  • When putting a no-challenge clause into a license agreement or accepting one, we suggest looking at two things together. The Supreme Court did not decide the effect of a no-challenge agreement in this decision. The review guidelines of the Korea Fair Trade Commission give the unfair imposition of a no-challenge obligation as an example of the imposition of unfair conditions. Where a business entity exercises an intellectual property right on its own, the Guidelines apply, in principle, to a business entity that holds market-dominant power.
  • We suggest that a licensee weigh the gains and losses of a trial for invalidation against the agreement. Under the Supreme Court decisions, license fees already paid are, in principle, not returned. The obligation to pay license fees for the period during which the license agreement validly existed also remains in principle.
  • Right after registration, a request for revocation of a granted patent can also be considered. Any person may file a request for revocation of a granted patent, but the period and the grounds are limited.

FAQ

Can a licensee in Korea file a petition for a trial for invalidation of the patent for which it holds a license?

In principle, yes. It may be that a licensee does not face, or has no reason to fear, an assertion of the patent right by the patentee. The Supreme Court held that, barring special circumstances, the interest cannot be found to have been extinguished merely for that reason. [1]

Who is an “interested party” who may file a petition for a trial for invalidation?

It is a person who suffers or is likely to suffer a legal disadvantage from the continued existence of the right in the patented invention. Persons who manufacture and sell, or will manufacture and sell, goods of the same kind as that patented invention are also included. [1]

What are the “special circumstances” in which a licensee can no longer file the petition?

The Supreme Court did not give an example. [1] The lower court, the IP High Court of Korea, gave examples such as the case where the licensee can be regarded as having acquired the patent right itself. [2]

Does this decision apply as it is to the current Patent Act?

What the Supreme Court interpreted is the former part of Art. 133(1) before amendment by Act No. 11654. The current Art. 133(1) also names an interested party or an examiner as the petitioner. However, the current provision places a limitation on the ground in the main clause of subparagraph 2. The Supreme Court did not directly interpret the current provision. [1] [5]

If the invalidation of the patent becomes final and conclusive, are the license fees paid until then returned?

In principle, no. The Supreme Court held that the patentee has no obligation to return the license fees that correspond to the period during which the license agreement validly existed. This does not hold if the license agreement was impossible to perform from the outset, or if the license agreement itself has a separate ground for invalidity. [4]

How DEFINE IP Law Firm handles this

At the stage of reviewing a trial for invalidation, DEFINE IP Law Firm first checks the petitioner’s interest. If the petitioner is a licensee, we read the clauses of the license agreement against the standard of this decision. We do not present content that is not in the written judgment as the standard of the decision. For questions about trials for invalidation and licenses in Korea, please write to contact@defineip.kr.

Sources

  1. Supreme Court en banc Decision 2017Hu2819 Decided February 21, 2019 (대법원 2019. 2. 21. 선고 2017후2819 전원합의체 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2017후2819) (verified 2026-10-09)
  2. Patent Court Decision 2017Heo2727 Decided October 27, 2017 (특허법원 2017. 10. 27. 선고 2017허2727 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2017허2727) (verified 2026-10-09)
  3. Supreme Court Decision 82Hu58 Decided December 27, 1983 (대법원 1983. 12. 27. 선고 82후58 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(82후58) (verified 2026-10-09)
  4. Supreme Court Decision 2012Da42666, 42673 Decided November 13, 2014 (대법원 2014. 11. 13. 선고 2012다42666, 42673 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2012다42666) (verified 2026-10-09)
  5. Patent Act (특허법), Act No. 21134, in force from 2025-11-11. Art. 52(4), Art. 100, Art. 102, Art. 132-2, Art. 133(1) and (3). https://www.law.go.kr/법령/특허법 (verified 2026-10-09)
  6. Patent Act (특허법), Act No. 11117, in force from 2012-03-15 (Art. 133(1) before the amendment). Patent Act, Act No. 11654, promulgated on 2013-03-22, in force from 2013-07-01, Art. 133(1) and Addenda, Art. 1. Patent Act, Act No. 14035, promulgated on 2016-02-29, in force from 2017-03-01, Art. 132-2, Art. 133 and Addenda, Art. 1, Art. 10 and Art. 21. Patent Act, Act No. 18505, promulgated on 2021-10-19, in force from 2022-04-20, Art. 133(1), subparagraph 7 and Addenda, Art. 1, Art. 3(2) and Art. 4. Version history at https://www.law.go.kr/법령/특허법 (verified 2026-10-09)
  7. Patent Act (특허법), Act No. 21955, promulgated on 2026-09-15, in force from 2027-03-16. Art. 132-2 and Art. 133. https://www.law.go.kr/법령/특허법 (verified 2026-10-09)
  8. Utility Model Act (실용신안법), Act No. 21065, in force from 2025-10-01, Art. 31(1). Design Protection Act (디자인보호법), Act No. 21065, in force from 2025-11-28, Art. 121(1). Trademark Act (상표법), Act No. 21134, in force from 2025-11-11, Art. 117(1). Versions not yet in force: Utility Model Act (Act No. 21953) and Design Protection Act (Act No. 21951), both promulgated on 2026-09-15, in force from 2027-03-16. https://www.law.go.kr/법령/실용신안법 , https://www.law.go.kr/법령/디자인보호법 , https://www.law.go.kr/법령/상표법 (verified 2026-10-09)
  9. Korea Fair Trade Commission (공정거래위원회), Review Guidelines on Unfair Exercise of Intellectual Property Rights (지식재산권의 부당한 행사에 대한 심사지침), Korea Fair Trade Commission Established Rule No. 389 (공정거래위원회예규 제389호), in force from 2021-12-30. Ⅰ.2.나, Ⅱ.2.나, Ⅲ.3.라.(6) and its reference note. https://www.law.go.kr/행정규칙/지식재산권의부당한행사에대한심사지침 (verified 2026-10-09)
  10. Supreme Court Decision 2018Da287362 Decided April 25, 2019 (대법원 2019. 4. 25. 선고 2018다287362 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2018다287362) (verified 2026-10-09)