← 글 목록← All articles

Supreme Court en banc Decision 2009Hu2234 Decided January 19, 2012: when is a repeated petition for trial barred in Korea?

Brief summary

  • The Supreme Court of Korea changed the reference time by an en banc decision of 19 January 2012. Whether a petition for trial becomes unlawful under res judicata (일사부재리), a bar on a repeated petition for trial on the same facts and evidence, is determined as of the time when the petition for trial is filed. There are cases where, after a petition for trial is filed, a trial decision in another trial based on the same facts and evidence becomes final and conclusive and is registered. The Supreme Court held that, in that situation, the petition for trial cannot be held unlawful under res judicata. [1]
  • The provision that this decision interpreted is Article 163 of the Patent Act (특허법) before its amendment, which required that the trial decision be “final and conclusive and registered” (확정 등록). The requirement in the current Article 163 is that the trial decision be “final and conclusive” (확정). [1] [7] [8]
  • The Supreme Court explained the scope of this decision in a 2020 decision. This decision changed the reference time to the time of the petition for trial only in relation to whether the earlier trial decision has become final and conclusive. Whether a petition is based on the same facts and evidence is determined as of the time of the trial decision. [2]

Last verified

The case

Item Details
Court Supreme Court of Korea
Date of decision January 19, 2012
Case number 2009Hu2234
Case name Invalidation of Registration (Patent)
Remand Judgment of the Supreme Court Supreme Court Decision 2006Hu435 Decided November 13, 2008
Lower court It is the lower court after the remand. The written judgment published by the Ministry of Government Legislation (법제처) does not give the case number of the lower court
Result The final appeal is dismissed
En banc This is an en banc decision. It was made by the assent of all participating Justices
Reference Provisions (written judgment) Former Patent Act (before amendment by Act No. 6411 of February 3, 2001), Art. 163
Decisions overruled Supreme Court Decision 97Hu3661 Decided June 23, 2000; Supreme Court Decision 2003Hu427 Decided May 26, 2006

The contents of this table are taken from the written judgment. [1]

The issue: what happens if another trial decision becomes final and conclusive and is registered after the petition for trial is filed?

The issue is the time as of which it is determined whether the principle of res judicata applies. There are two candidates. One is the time when the petition for trial is filed, and the other is the time when the trial decision in that trial is made. [1]

The provision applied in this case is Article 163 of the Patent Act before its amendment by Act No. 6411 of 3 February 2001. This provision set as its requirement the time when a trial decision in a trial under the Patent Act has become final and conclusive and been registered, or a judgment has become final and conclusive. In that event, no person can file a petition for that trial on the basis of the same facts and evidence. [1] [8]

The facts are as follows. The names of the parties are not given. [1]

Date Event
2 December 2003 The petitioner filed a petition for a trial for invalidation of the patent against the patentees. The grounds were lack of inventive step and others
30 October 2004 The Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board (IPTAB, 특허심판원) made a trial decision dismissing this petition on the merits
12 January 2006 The lower court before the remand dismissed the petitioner’s claim
17 February 2006 Another company filed a petition for a trial for invalidation of some of the claims of the same patent
6 October 2007 The trial decision dismissing the other company’s petition on the merits became final and conclusive
20 November 2007 That final and conclusive trial decision was registered in the patent register
13 November 2008 The Supreme Court reversed the judgment of the lower court before the remand and remanded the case to the lower court

The other company’s trial took the following course. On 25 July 2006, the IPTAB made a trial decision granting the petition. On 4 May 2007, the Intellectual Property High Court of Korea (Patent Court of Korea) revoked that trial decision, and this judgment became final and conclusive as it stood. On 30 August 2007, the IPTAB made a trial decision dismissing the petition on the merits, in accordance with the judgment of revocation. [1]

The two trials overlapped in some of the claims. The Supreme Court found that the part concerning those claims was a petition that sought denial of inventive step on the basis of the same two pieces of evidence. [1]

Under the earlier precedents, the reference time was the time of the trial decision. Under the earlier precedents, if another trial decision had already become final and conclusive and been registered at the time of the trial decision, res judicata applied, without asking whether the petition had been filed before that. [1] [4]

The lower court after the remand found that there was no violation of res judicata. It gave two reasons. The other company’s final and conclusive trial decision had not been registered on 30 October 2004, the time of the trial decision in this case. The two added pieces of evidence were strong evidence capable of reversing the final and conclusive trial decision, and so were not the same evidence. The lower court found that the inventive step of the patented invention was denied. [1]

What the court held 1: the reference time is the time when the petition for trial is filed

The Supreme Court held that the reference time must be “the time when the petition for trial was filed”. Where a trial decision in another trial becomes final and conclusive and is registered only after the petition for trial was filed, that petition cannot be held unlawful under res judicata. [1]

The Supreme Court gave three reasons. [1]

The first is the result of the earlier precedents. It concerns the case where several petitions for trial based on the same facts and evidence are filed against the same patent. While an action requesting revocation of a decision rendered by the IPTAB (legal proceedings against trial rulings) is pending against the trial decision in one trial, the trial decision in another trial may become final and conclusive and be registered. Under the earlier precedents, even if the court revokes the former trial decision, the IPTAB has no choice but to dismiss that petition when it makes a trial decision again. The Supreme Court described this as the procedure becoming unlawful retroactively because of a “fortuitous circumstance”. The Supreme Court found that this may excessively infringe the people’s right to a trial. It also pointed to the unreasonable result that the judgment of the court that revoked the trial decision becomes meaningless. [1]

Article 189(2) of the Patent Act provides that, when a judgment revoking a trial decision or a decision becomes final and conclusive, the administrative patent judges must examine the case again and make a trial decision or a decision. [7]

The second is the range of persons bound by the effect. The former Article 163 of the Patent Act set that range as “any person” (누구든지). A person who is neither a party to the final and conclusive and registered trial decision nor a successor of such a party also cannot file a petition for the same trial. The Supreme Court stated that widening the scope of application without care would restrict the exercise of the right to a trial. [1]

The third is the wording of the provision. The former Article 163 of the Patent Act provided that a person “cannot file a petition for that trial”. The Supreme Court interpreted this wording as meaning only that a new petition for trial is not allowed after the trial decision has become final and conclusive and been registered. [1]

The Supreme Court also stated the purpose of the provision. One purpose is to prevent abuse of petitions for trial and so promote the economy of the trial procedure. The other is to spare the other party the burden of having to respond to the same trial repeatedly. [1]

The former Article 163 of the Patent Act also set the time when a judgment has become final and conclusive as a requirement. Of the two cases, the Supreme Court stated its reasoning only for the case where a trial decision has become final and conclusive and been registered. [1]

What the court held 2: the petition for trial in this case does not violate res judicata

The Supreme Court agreed with the lower court in the conclusion and differed in the reasons. [1]

  • The Supreme Court found that the part concerning the overlapping claims was a petition for trial based on the same facts and evidence. [1]
  • The Supreme Court found that the two added pieces of evidence were not strong evidence capable of reversing the final and conclusive trial decision. This is because the inventive step of the overlapping claims is denied on the original two pieces of evidence alone. [1]
  • The other company’s final and conclusive trial decision had not been registered on 2 December 2003, the time when the petition for trial in this case was filed. Therefore, the petition for trial in this case does not violate the principle of res judicata. [1]

The Supreme Court stated that two findings of the lower court were wrong. They are the finding that the reference time is the time of the trial decision and the finding that the two added pieces of evidence were not the same evidence. The Supreme Court found that the conclusion of the lower court was correct in the result and dismissed the final appeal. [1]

When is a repeated trial request barred in Korea?
Dates in case 2009Hu2234

Before and after this decision: the two decisions overruled and the two decisions of 2020

The decisions that this decision overruled

The Supreme Court overruled the purport of two decisions to the extent that they are inconsistent with this decision. [1]

Decision Standard before the change
Supreme Court Decision 97Hu3661 Decided June 23, 2000 Whether res judicata applies is determined as of the time of the trial decision, not the time when the petition for trial is filed [4]
Supreme Court Decision 2003Hu427 Decided May 26, 2006 The earlier trial decision need not have become final and conclusive and been registered when the new petition for trial is filed. If it has become final and conclusive and been registered when the trial decision in the new trial is made, the new petition for trial may become unlawful [5]

The 2006 decision is a case on a trial to confirm the scope of a trademark right. The provision that this decision cited is Article 147 of the former Patent Act, which Article 51 of the former Trademark Act applied mutatis mutandis. Both Acts are the versions before they were wholly amended on 13 January 1990. [5]

The 2020 decision 1: the same facts and evidence are assessed as of the time of the trial decision

Supreme Court Decision 2018Hu11360 Decided April 9, 2020 explained the scope of the 2012 decision. The 2012 decision is a decision in a case where the issue was the reference time for determining whether the earlier trial decision has become final and conclusive. The Supreme Court stated that the 2012 decision changed the reference time from the time of the trial decision to the time of the petition for trial “only in relation to” whether the earlier trial decision has become final and conclusive. [2]

The reference time for the same facts and evidence is different. An amendment to a petition for trial cannot change its gist, but an amendment to the grounds for the petition is allowed (Patent Act, Art. 140(2), subparagraph 2). [2] [7] Therefore, the IPTAB takes into account all the facts and evidence as amended between the filing of the petition for trial and the time of the trial decision. The IPTAB determines, as of the time of the trial decision, whether the petition for trial is based on the same facts and evidence as the earlier final and conclusive trial decision. [2]

The 2020 decision set two more points. A petition for trial that violates Article 163 is unlawful and must be dismissed, whoever filed it. There is also a limit in a revocation action against a trial decision of dismissal on the ground of a violation of res judicata. The petitioner cannot assert a new ground for invalidation that was not asserted in the trial procedure. [2]

The lower court in case 2018Hu11360 relied on the 2012 decision and stated that the reference time for the same facts and evidence is also the time of the petition for trial. The Supreme Court stated that this part was wrong. [2]

The 2020 decision 2: the prohibition of a duplicate petition for trial is assessed as of the time of the trial decision

Supreme Court Decision 2016Hu2317 Decided April 29, 2020 dealt with the prohibition of a duplicate petition for trial (중복심판청구 금지). It concerns the case where, for a trial pending before the IPTAB (the earlier trial), the same party files a petition for the same trial again (the later trial). Article 154(8) of the Patent Act applies Article 259 of the Civil Procedure Act (민사소송법) mutatis mutandis to trials. [3] [7] Article 259 of the Civil Procedure Act provides that a party cannot institute a lawsuit again for a case pending before a court. [12]

Article 259 of the Civil Procedure Act has been in Article 154(8) since Act No. 7871, promulgated on 3 March 2006. This amended provision entered into force on 1 October 2006. Article 6 of the Addenda to Act No. 7871 is a general transitional measure. Under it, the former provisions apply to a trial on a patent application filed under the former provisions at the time that Act entered into force. The proviso to Article 6 of the Addenda does not list Article 154(8). [8]

The Supreme Court held that whether the earlier trial is pending must be assessed as of the time of the trial decision in the later trial. If the pendency of the earlier trial has ended by the time of the trial decision, the later trial does not violate the prohibition of a duplicate petition for trial. The Supreme Court stated that the prohibition of a duplicate petition for trial and the principle of res judicata differ in their requirements and scope of application. Therefore, it stated, the determination is not to be made as of the time of the petition for the later trial by relying on the 2012 decision. [3]

There is a place where the two standards meet. It is the case where the later trial is petitioned while the earlier trial is pending, and the trial decision in the earlier trial becomes final and conclusive before the trial decision in the later trial. The lower court in case 2016Hu2317 stated that, in that situation, neither the prohibition of a duplicate petition for trial nor res judicata applies to the later trial. The lower court called this an “unavoidable gap” that arises from taking the time of the petition for trial as the reference time for res judicata. The Supreme Court stated that the finding of the lower court did not err by misapprehending the legal principle on the prohibition of a duplicate petition for trial. The Supreme Court also did not accept the ground of appeal on the principle of res judicata. [3]

Other decisions: strong evidence

Supreme Court Decision 2012Hu1057 Decided September 13, 2013 dealt with the same evidence under the former Article 163 of the Patent Act. Where strong evidence capable of reversing the conclusion of the final and conclusive trial decision is newly submitted, there is no conflict with the principle of res judicata. [6] The 2012 en banc decision also examined whether the added evidence was strong evidence. [1]

Other decisions: the proviso on a trial decision of dismissal

Supreme Court Decision 2021Hu10077 Decided June 3, 2021 dealt with the proviso to Article 163 of the Patent Act. If the final and conclusive trial decision is a trial decision that dismissed the petition for trial because it did not meet the requirements for a lawful petition, it does not have the effect of res judicata. The Supreme Court stated that the proviso also applies to a trial decision that dismissed a petition on the ground that it was a petition for trial based on the same evidence as an earlier final and conclusive trial decision. The same holds for a trial decision of dismissal made after examining and determining whether the new evidence is strong evidence. [13]

Has any decision overruled this decision?

The case search of the Ministry of Government Legislation returned no decision that overruled this decision (searched on 9 October 2026). The two 2020 decisions above did not overrule this decision but explained its scope. [2] [3]

Has the provision that this decision interpreted changed since then?

It has changed. The amendment came before the decision. The provision before the amendment was applied in this case. [1]

Version Wording of Article 163
Before amendment by Act No. 6411 When a trial decision has become final and conclusive and been registered, or a judgment has become final and conclusive, no person can file a petition for that trial on the basis of the same facts and evidence [8]
Act No. 6411 (promulgated on 3 February 2001, in force from 1 July 2001) When a trial decision has become final and conclusive, no person can file a petition for trial again on that case on the basis of the same facts and evidence. This does not apply where the final and conclusive trial decision is a trial decision of dismissal [8]
From Act No. 12753 (promulgated on 11 June 2014, in force from 1 January 2015) to the current version (Act No. 21134, in force from 11 November 2025) When a trial decision has become final and conclusive, no person can file a petition for trial again on that case on the basis of the same facts and evidence. This does not apply where the final and conclusive trial decision is a trial decision of dismissal [7]

Act No. 6411 changed three things. The words “registered” (등록) and “when a judgment has become final and conclusive” (판결이 확정된 때) were removed from the requirements. The words “on that case” (그 사건에 대하여는) and “again” (다시) were inserted. A proviso on a trial decision of dismissal was created. [7] [8]

Paragraph (3) of the Addenda to Act No. 6411 is a general transitional measure. Under it, the former provisions apply to a trial on a patent application filed under the former provisions at the time that Act entered into force. The subparagraphs of the proviso to paragraph (3) of the Addenda do not list Article 163. [8] The 2012 decision did not separately state why it applied the provision before the amendment. [1]

The current sentence of Article 163 came in when Act No. 12753 wholly amended the Article. This Act was promulgated on 11 June 2014 and entered into force on 1 January 2015. Article 8 of the Addenda to this Act also contains a general transitional measure. Under it, the former provisions apply to patent applications filed before that Act entered into force and to the examination and trials on patent applications. [8]

The 2012 decision interpreted the provision before the amendment, which required that the trial decision be “final and conclusive and registered”. [1] Act No. 6411 deleted “registered” from the requirement, and since then the requirement in Article 163 has been that the trial decision be “final and conclusive”. [7] [8]

Decision 2018Hu11360 quoted the wording of Article 163 that requires the trial decision to be “final and conclusive”. The two 2020 decisions described the standard of the 2012 decision as one on “whether the earlier trial decision has become final and conclusive”. [2] [3] In case 2016Hu2317, the trial decision in the earlier trial became final and conclusive after the later trial was petitioned. The lower court found that the principle of res judicata does not apply to the later trial, and the Supreme Court stated that this finding was not wrong. [3]

An amendment to the Patent Act was promulgated on 15 September 2026 as Act No. 21955, and this amendment enters into force on 16 March 2027. Article 163 in this version has the same wording as the current one. The wording of Articles 140, 154 and 189 is also the same as the current one. [7]

Do trademarks, designs and utility models have the same provision?

Yes. Article 150 of the Trademark Act (상표법) and Article 151 of the Design Protection Act (디자인보호법) each provide for res judicata separately. The two provisions use the words “같은 사실 및 같은 증거” (the same facts and the same evidence). They also have a proviso on a trial decision of dismissal. [9] [10] Article 33 of the Utility Model Act (실용신안법) applies Articles 159 through 164 of the Patent Act mutatis mutandis to trials on utility models. [11] Amendments to the Design Protection Act and the Utility Model Act that enter into force on 16 March 2027 have also been promulgated. The wording of Article 151 of the Design Protection Act and Article 33 of the Utility Model Act in those versions is the same as the current one. [10] [11]

The 2012 decision interpreted the former Article 163 of the Patent Act. This decision did not directly interpret Article 150 of the Trademark Act or Article 151 of the Design Protection Act. [1]

The whole procedure of a trial for invalidation of a patent is covered in “How does a trial for invalidation work in Korea?“.

What changes in practice

The following is the opinion of our firm. The points below assume the wording of the current Article 163. Which version of Article 163 applies must be read together with the transitional measures in the Addenda described above. Whether res judicata applies in an individual case depends on the facts, so please check with your agent.

  • For a party that intends to file a petition for a trial for invalidation, we suggest first checking the other trials pending against the same patent. A petition for trial filed before the trial decision in another trial becomes final and conclusive does not become unlawful under res judicata, even if that trial decision later becomes final and conclusive.
  • If the petition is filed after the trial decision in another trial has already become final and conclusive, in general the facts or the evidence must be different. New evidence must be strong evidence capable of reversing the conclusion of the final and conclusive trial decision. If the final and conclusive trial decision is a trial decision of dismissal, a petition can be filed again under the proviso to Article 163.
  • We suggest submitting all grounds for invalidation and all evidence at the trial stage. Whether the petition is based on the same facts and evidence is determined as of the time of the trial decision. In the litigation after a dismissal under res judicata, a new ground for invalidation cannot be asserted.
  • For a patentee, we suggest checking, even after a trial decision has become final and conclusive, whether other trials petitioned before that remain. Such a trial does not become unlawful under res judicata because of the trial decision that became final and conclusive later.
  • Where the same party files a petition for the same trial again, the prohibition of a duplicate petition for trial is checked separately. The reference time for it is the time of the trial decision in the later trial.

FAQ

If a trial decision in a trial for invalidation petitioned by another person becomes final and conclusive, am I also unable to file a petition for trial?

A petition based on the same facts and evidence cannot be filed. Article 163 of the Patent Act sets the persons bound as “any person”. This does not apply if the final and conclusive trial decision is a trial decision of dismissal. [7]

If another person’s trial decision becomes final and conclusive first, after I have filed my petition for trial, is my petition dismissed?

Under the 2012 en banc decision, it does not become unlawful under res judicata. The reference time is the time when the petition for trial is filed. [1]

As of what time is it determined whether the facts and evidence are the same?

The time of the trial decision. The Supreme Court stated in a 2020 decision that all the facts and evidence as amended between the filing of the petition for trial and the time of the trial decision are taken into account. [2]

The 2012 decision concerns the provision before the amendment. Is it still the standard?

The Supreme Court dealt with this decision in the two 2020 decisions. Decision 2018Hu11360 quoted the wording of Article 163 that requires the trial decision to be “final and conclusive”. The Supreme Court explained that this decision changed the reference time to the time of the petition for trial only in relation to whether the earlier trial decision has become final and conclusive. [2] [3] The case search of the Ministry of Government Legislation returned no decision that overruled this decision (searched on 9 October 2026).

How DEFINE IP Law Firm handles this

At the stage of preparing a trial for invalidation, DEFINE IP Law Firm checks the status of other trials against the same patent. If there is a final and conclusive trial decision, we compare the facts and evidence of that trial decision with the facts and evidence of the new petition. We do not present as the standard of a decision anything that is not in the written judgment. For questions about the trial for invalidation and res judicata in Korea, please write to contact@defineip.kr.

Sources

  1. Supreme Court of Korea (대법원), Supreme Court en banc Decision 2009Hu2234 Decided January 19, 2012 (대법원 2012. 1. 19. 선고 2009후2234 전원합의체 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2009후2234) (verified 9 October 2026)
  2. Supreme Court of Korea, Supreme Court Decision 2018Hu11360 Decided April 9, 2020 (대법원 2020. 4. 9. 선고 2018후11360 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2018후11360) (verified 9 October 2026)
  3. Supreme Court of Korea, Supreme Court Decision 2016Hu2317 Decided April 29, 2020 (대법원 2020. 4. 29. 선고 2016후2317 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2016후2317) (verified 9 October 2026)
  4. Supreme Court of Korea, Supreme Court Decision 97Hu3661 Decided June 23, 2000 (대법원 2000. 6. 23. 선고 97후3661 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(97후3661) (verified 9 October 2026)
  5. Supreme Court of Korea, Supreme Court Decision 2003Hu427 Decided May 26, 2006 (대법원 2006. 5. 26. 선고 2003후427 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2003후427) (verified 9 October 2026)
  6. Supreme Court of Korea, Supreme Court Decision 2012Hu1057 Decided September 13, 2013 (대법원 2013. 9. 13. 선고 2012후1057 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2012후1057) (verified 9 October 2026)
  7. Patent Act (특허법), Act No. 21134, in force from 2025-11-11. Art. 140, Art. 154, Art. 163, Art. 189. Patent Act, Act No. 21955, promulgated on 2026-09-15, scheduled to enter into force on 2027-03-16. Art. 140, Art. 154, Art. 163, Art. 189. https://www.law.go.kr/법령/특허법 (verified 9 October 2026)
  8. Patent Act, Act No. 6024, in force from 2000-10-01 (Art. 163 before the amendment). Patent Act, Act No. 6411, promulgated on 2001-02-03, in force from 2001-07-01, Art. 163 and Addenda paragraph (3). Patent Act, Act No. 7871, promulgated on 2006-03-03, the amended provision of Art. 154(8) in force from 2006-10-01, Art. 154(8) and Addenda Art. 1 and Art. 6. Patent Act, Act No. 12753, promulgated on 2014-06-11, in force from 2015-01-01, Art. 163 and Addenda Art. 8. Version history at https://www.law.go.kr/법령/특허법 (verified 9 October 2026)
  9. Trademark Act (상표법), Act No. 21134, in force from 2025-11-11. Art. 150. https://www.law.go.kr/법령/상표법 (verified 9 October 2026)
  10. Design Protection Act (디자인보호법), Act No. 21065, in force from 2025-11-28. Art. 151. Design Protection Act, Act No. 21951, promulgated on 2026-09-15, scheduled to enter into force on 2027-03-16. Art. 151. https://www.law.go.kr/법령/디자인보호법 (verified 9 October 2026)
  11. Utility Model Act (실용신안법), Act No. 21065, in force from 2025-10-01. Art. 33. Utility Model Act, Act No. 21953, promulgated on 2026-09-15, scheduled to enter into force on 2027-03-16. Art. 33. https://www.law.go.kr/법령/실용신안법 (verified 9 October 2026)
  12. Civil Procedure Act (민사소송법), Act No. 21993, in force from 2026-10-02. Art. 259. https://www.law.go.kr/법령/민사소송법 (verified 9 October 2026)
  13. Supreme Court of Korea, Supreme Court Decision 2021Hu10077 Decided June 3, 2021 (대법원 2021. 6. 3. 선고 2021후10077 판결). https://www.law.go.kr/판례/(2021후10077) (verified 9 October 2026)